On Tue, Jul 14, 2009 at 1:22 PM, OrionWorks <[email protected]>wrote:

> John,
>
> You have stated:
>
> > I saw this and then read his comment, so I knew
> > what he was talking about and I had the same objection,
> > this disproves the person claiming his 10 year old faked it.
>
> There are many prosaic reasons why a glowing "ring" would begin to
> fade out as this alleged UFO appears to ascend into a bank of clouds.
> Who is not aware of the phenomenon where a flashlight as its
> directional beam points farther away from the viewpoint of the
> observer naturally begins to fade in intensity.


That is plainly not what is occurring.

>
>
> ...and
>
> > Also the camera is moving quite a lot, a reflection would
> > move with the observer not remain stationary in the
> > background.
>
> This analysis makes no sense. It's obvious the camera is jiggling
> about, but not in back and forth movements in relationship to the
> ground as your conjecture seems to be based on.


No, my conjecture is based on side to side wiggle.
Go to a window, look at a reflection of a light and think of it as a ufo in
the distance.
Then jiggle your head a little.
The UFO zooms over the background with each little movement.
Plainly the camera is not being held very still but even a slight jiggle
sends the UFO moving in a readily observible way.


>
> And finally, your comment:
>
> > The person claiming it was hoaxed IS himself a hoaxer.
>
> ... and at this point I realize this is just all getting too silly.
>
> What is your point, John? Actually, what's the "point" you conjecture
> I have missed? I'm baffled. Is it your conjecture that I refuse
> consider the possibility that this a real UFO?


I said I think it's probably CGI.
My point is I have one is that I can't understand why anyone can possibly
fail to see the errors in the claims made in the article.

Or are you implying
> that I still believe that this incident could still be a real UFO,
> despite what the kid's father has to say on the subject?


I mean no offense to you at all but I am starting to wonder if I am speaking
(well, typing) english.

I have no argument with people who believe it's real or which those that
believe it is a hoax.

 I do have an argument with anyone that can fail to see what is just poorly
done debunking and take it hook line and sinker.

I am fast coming to the conclusion that I should make a video of what a
reflection looks like just so people can grasp the obvious.

What is equally amazing to me is why on youtube and now you too (again, no
offense intended) can fail to understand me when I say "I believe it is
faked with CGI probably but definitely NOT a reflection" and yet can accuse
me of wanting to believe it is real!


>
> After viewing and listening to this video countless times, after
> listening to the voice of child and what appears to be the voice of
> the mother in the background who is obviously enjoying playing along
> with her children, it seems pretty obvious to me that everyone was
> having a bang up of a time. Unexpected creativity, the sudden magic of
> the moment is wonderful play! Why is this so difficult for anyone to
> grasp?
>

What is so hard to grasp with "It is simply not possible for that to be a
reflection".
It should be immediatly obvious, and once it has been mentioned by Robin and
myself surely a look in a pane of glass would be the natural next step
before replying.

Also how was anyone able to misunderstand Robin? He was clearly pointing out
the exact same thing.

And then we have the father's subsequent Denver post article,


And how do we know he is the father?

>
> his retelling of what his wonderfully creative kids did one day on the
> spur of the moment, the subsequent posting of their creation out on
> You-Tube and the unexpected surprise of countless individuals and UFO
> organizations refusing to accept that this was mere child's play. And
> then you are giving me the impression that you as well appear to
> dismiss the father's account.


Yes, based on it being impossible and there being no evidence that he is the
father, just a writer wanting to promote his book and website.


> I think these kids are laughing their
> heads off, and rightly so as they teach their parents, us old timers,
> a valuable lesson about the chameleon-like nature of the Internet:
> "The net of a thousand lies!" What a hoot!


Yeah, well you must use LOGIC not just believing everything you read to sort
through the lies.

Reply via email to