In case there is any doubt, the following is my final answer - unless of course I find other mistakes! 8^)

On Dec 29, 2009, at 8:44 AM, Horace Heffner wrote:


Hi Rick,

Coincidentally, I saw something similar yesterday (Dec 28, 2009) around noon AKST, (about 11 orbits later) west of Palmer AK, but heading SW. It was one small finger width at arms length above the horizon. It had a periodic (about 10 second) flash to it, so I assumed it might be a booster, but strange it was heading SW, not SE or NE, or just S. Of course a U-turn is not a typical satellite maneuver, nor did I see that!

The altitude h to the directly overhead sun midline is given by:

   h = r_earth * ( SQRT(1 + sin^2 theta) -1)

Given time after sunset t we have:

theta = (t/(8.64x10^4 s))*(2*Pi) radians = (t/(1440 min))*(2*Pi) radians

Earth radius, r_earth, at Hawaii is about 3951 mi. Here are some numbers:

t (min) theta (radians) h (miles)
                
1       0.00436331944   0.03760073165
5       0.02181659722   0.93976780755
10      0.04363319444   3.75594358
20      0.08726638889   14.973936498
30      0.13089958333   33.506081478
60      0.26179916667   130.1553394
90      0.39269875      279.3533269


Since the above is time after total sunset, you don't have to correct for the angular width of the sun. However, even total sunset is not good enough to black out an object though, due to light diffraction. Clearly not enough time, i.e. "shortly after sunset", passed to rule out an airplane.

Best regards,

Horace Heffner
http://www.mtaonline.net/~hheffner/




Reply via email to