On Sat, Dec 24, 2011 at 2:35 PM, David Roberson <dlrober...@aol.com> wrote:
> Mary, it is quite unfortunate that he does not want to share additional > information concerning his model. This is just the sort of model that is > needed to determine whether or not it is possible to replicate Rossi > results with heat storage. I am trying to keep an open mind as much as > possible in this case and really would like to proceed with more details. > Please discuss this with the guy and let me know if he really wants to find > the truth. I can only assume that he is hiding something if he runs like > this when asked probing questions. I have many more items to compare. > > It might be possible that I am reading your friends output in an erroneous > manner. I thought that he had a direct model of the temperature at T2 just > as with the real ECAT. Why would we not compare these two curves if they > are available? This is more like comparing apples with apples versus some > other parameter. Does he in fact calculate the water temperature or did I > miss something? > > By the way, it is nonsense to suggest that this is like showing that Santa > does not exist. I am maintaining an open mind regarding whether or not > Rossi is real in this case and it would be a crime to assume otherwise. I > seek the truth only. > > Dave > Hi Dave, After Xmas, I'll approach him to see if he wants to continue. I doubt he has anything to hide but he's busy and Rossi to him is just a diversion. I'm pretty sure he does calculate the output water temperature. I will look again later at the curves and ask him about it. I have also suggested to him to get his own anonymous email and to interact directly. The Santa reference doesn't refer to you or to anyone else who has an open mind and includes in their thinking the substantial probability that Rossi does not have what he claims and that his experiments were in some way deceptive. I suspect it's about people who write like Jed and Aussieguy but then, it wasn't my analogy so I really don't know. Merry Xmas. M. Y.
