Mary Yugo asked a sensible question: Why are these people wearing overcoats
standing next to a 12 kW heater?

She then said:

"This is sort of a trivial matter and can't be settled for sure without
cooperation from Rossi or Levi which I am certain won't be forthcoming,
LOLOLOL!     I only talked about it for the amusement value."

That is wrong. You can settle this without cooperation from Rossi. As I
said, you can stand next to a 12 kW water heater for a while, measure
ambient temperature several times over an hour and a half, and you will see
that it does not heat up the room much.

It also helps to know that people in Europe tend to keep buildings cold.

As I described here, on December 7 I did a simpleminded, crude test with
water flowing through pipes. This is actually less crude than it seems. I
put some thought into it. I believe it simulates the effects of pipes
placed close together with an air envelope transferring heat from one pipe
to the other.  I think I showed that those effects are negligible. They are
so small they cannot be measured with the ordinary instruments used by HVAC
people or by Rossi. With all due respect, I think I did a better job than
Vorl Bek, who addressed the same question but failed to insulate the heat
source. He did not trap the air, so that is an invalid test.

There is a great deal of value in doing simpleminded tests with ordinary
thermometers to familiarize yourself with equipment of this size and scale.
I think that Yugo and others should try this, even though it makes you feel
like a Boy Scout or a middle school kid doing a science fair project. Yugo
laughs at her own question, "LOLOLOL . . . amusement value . . ." It it not
amusing. It is a good question. But she failed to see that the answer is
pretty obvious. You have to be familiar with water heaters to critique
Rossi's tests.

I fooled around with water heaters and thermometers at Hydrodynamics, at
Gene's lab, and at home at various times. Just to get a feel for it. That's
the key thing: *get a feel for it*. Learn what to expect. Learn what 12 kW
flame looks like, and what hot water from a 12 kW heater feels like.

I have also done months of work with laboratory scale calorimeters
operating at ~1 to ~100 W, when I worked with Gene Mallove, Mizuno and
others. That is more demanding. It is more "scientific." You use blanks and
so on, which no one does in HVAC-scale testing. I would not dare critique
calorimetry if I had not done this. Not to say I did such a great job, but
it was an essential learning experience. There are lot of issues such as
fluid mixing, the stability of thermocouples versus thermistors, flow rates
being too low, and so on, which you cannot understand without doing and
seeing. People who have not done hands-on lab work (however badly) are on
thin ice when they critique experiments. That is why I never talk about
mass spectroscopy. I know enough about it to know that I don't know enough
about it. I have translated a book chapter on this, and edited many papers,
so I get the general idea. But I have not *done it*, so I can't judge it.

- Jed

Reply via email to