On Fri, Jan 6, 2012 at 3:24 PM, Jed Rothwell <[email protected]> wrote:
> Mary Yugo asked a sensible question: Why are these people wearing > overcoats standing next to a 12 kW heater? > > She then said: > > "This is sort of a trivial matter and can't be settled for sure without > cooperation from Rossi or Levi which I am certain won't be forthcoming, > LOLOLOL! I only talked about it for the amusement value." > > That is wrong. You can settle this without cooperation from Rossi. As I > said, you can stand next to a 12 kW water heater for a while, measure > ambient temperature several times over an hour and a half, and you will see > that it does not heat up the room much. > > It also helps to know that people in Europe tend to keep buildings cold. > > As I described here, on December 7 I did a simpleminded, crude test with > water flowing through pipes. This is actually less crude than it seems. I > put some thought into it. I believe it simulates the effects of pipes > placed close together with an air envelope transferring heat from one pipe > to the other. I think I showed that those effects are negligible. They > are so small they cannot be measured with the ordinary instruments used by > HVAC people or by Rossi. With all due respect, I think I did a better job > than Vorl Bek, who addressed the same question but failed to insulate the > heat source. He did not trap the air, so that is an invalid test.<SNIP> > Hold on a moment. Rossi is SELLING THESE AS HEATERS (if he ever sells them). And also, he claimed to have one HEATING HIS FACTORY when he wrote his patent and he again claimed to have one HEATING A ROOM currently as per his blog. So I guess it is a reasonable question why he and Focardi are bundled up against cold in a room with a E-cat in it which, according to Rossi, could easily be used to HEAT THE ROOM. See my problem with all this? Nothing much of what these guys say and do makes much sense. Least of all planning to make a thousand HEATERS this year!

