That is a fair comment from the bleacher section, since superficially using "LENR" as an umbrella for everything related to hydrogen may make it seem like two miracles. However deuterium is completely different from hydrogen in so many ways that the two can be considered to be completely different fields of inquiry. Pd-D is clearly nuclear. Ni-H is not.
The deuteron is not a fermion and does not obey Fermi-Dirac statistics. Fermions contrast with bosons which obey Bose-Einstein statistics. The Pauli exclusion principle is another major difference. Plus there is far more mass difference between H and D than between C and O. Most other physical properties, are equally divergent in massive ways. Consider the H and D to be unrelated insofar as cooper paring is concerned - cannot happen with D. Consider them as different elements would be, in fact. In short, forget the bogus "two miracle" argument. But yes - it is true that all advances in physics begin with one miracle, major or minor, and we would like to conserve them, when possible. When one looks deeper at the Ni-H "miracle" and at nano and sub-nano geometry, then a major miracle begins to look minor, even mundane. In addition to tunneling, QM effects such as the Lamb shift turn up. Not to mention the Casimir effect (which can be either attractive or repulsive) and the dynamic Casimir effect DCE). Both the Lamb Shift and DCE portend anomalous heating AND anomalous cooling. The Lamb shift is a small difference in energy between two energy levels of the hydrogen atom in quantum electrodynamics (QED). This was the harbinger of modern QED as developed by Julian Schwinger and other - and was one of the main reasons that Schwinger was a proponent of LENR. The Lamb shift is tiny, but lattice phonons move a terahertz frequencies and higher, so the "transaction rate" for tiny incremental gain or loss, due to the Lamb shift, is staggering. Same with a dynamical Casimir effect. All one needs to realize either anomaly is to impose the asymmetry in a lasting way. In short, there is probably not even the single miracle here with Ni-H gain, since the main thing which is lacking now is independent replication. This will evolve into mainstream physics in a few years, if and when it is replicated independently (the need for replication is one reason for the delay in publication). Stay tuned. From: James Bowery In Brian Ahern's work on the "Arata effect", which... is NOT the F-P effect So we're witness to not one, but TWO miracles of energy production that just happen to involve hydrogen-metal systems? One miracle is enough to stretch credulity.
<<attachment: winmail.dat>>

