None of which addresses my empirical question: Does Pd+D (as does Ni+Cu+P) exhibit a negative coefficient of temperature as the Fleischmann Pons effect emerges from that system?
>From your argument below, I take it your answer is "No". On Sun, Jan 8, 2012 at 10:10 AM, Jones Beene <[email protected]> wrote: > Pd-D has surprisingly little in common with Ni-H, in theory or in > practice. **** > > ** ** > > As far as most physical and especially nuclear properties are concerned, > the fact that H and D are both chemically reactive volatile gases is the > main connection. In fact, on close inspection, it is a big surprise to most > observers that the two metals involved have more in common (physical > properties) than do the gases D and H. In fact, nickel and palladium are in > the same column (10) of the periodic table and are like two peas in a pod – > as far as physical properties go. Cost is another issue.**** > > ** ** > > In Pd-D reactions, there is a bona fide nuclear reaction resulting in > helium or tritium, plus the reactants are roughly 3 orders of magnitude > more costly than Ni-H. The transmutation ash of Pd-D can be polluting > (except for the helium); there is little that is renewable; transmutation > is common, gamma radiation is seen, and the capital investment will be > high. Most of all, Pd-D has never been scaled up to kilowatt level of > output. In short, Pd-D is a comparative loser as far as ultimate > commercialization is concerned. We have already seen in recent history the > price of palladium will soar to astronomical highs, with only a slight > change in supply. **** > > ** ** > > Little commercial opportunity exists for Pd-D, *if* and when Ni-H comes > to market, and it does work for thermal gain. Fully replicated evidence > goes back to the early nineties.**** > > ** ** > > Hydrogen is so completely different from deuterium that it can be > considered a separate element, instead of an isotope. The periodic table > which we have now, lumping the two together as isotopes, can be a bit > arbitrary and misleading insofar as it leads to incorrect assumptions about > many physical properties. The difference in physical and nuclear properties > between the two (D and H) is staggering – far more pronounced than two > elements in the same column of the periodic table, such as nickel and > palladium, for instance.**** > > ** ** > > Jones**** > > (see footnote)**** > > *From:* James Bowery **** > > > What I am talking about is the political economic miracle of an energy > revolution. What we are being asked to believe here is that there is > nothing in common between two revolutionary, non-polluting, virtually > renewable, low capital investment energy production systems that both > require hydrogen saturated metals (other than, of course, the fact that > they both involve metals saturated with hydrogen). We're supposed to > believe it is unreasonable to suspect such commonality because there are > differences in the isotopes of hydrogen used in the two systems.**** > > ** ** > > FOOTNOTE: **** > > ** ** > > Premise: Palladium is far closer in physical and nuclear properties to > Nickel, than deuterium is to hydrogen.**** > > ** ** > > The deuteron is a boson, not a fermion and does not obey Fermi–Dirac > statistics. Hydrogen (the proton) is a fermion, and in contrast to all > bosons like the deuteron, the proton does not obey Bose–Einstein > statistics. It cannot occupy the same quantum state with another proton. * > *** > > ** ** > > The Pauli exclusion principle is the major difference between the two, wrt > LENR - and it is precisely the factor which explains why deuterons will > fuse easily, while protons will not fuse (outside of solar-like gravity). > Plus there is far more mass difference between H and D than between Ni and > Pd. Most other physical properties, are equally divergent. **** > > ** ** > > If you consider the bulk of physical properties including density, > magnetic sensitivity, NMR receptivity, quadrupole moment, neutron capture > cross-section etc, etc. Hydrogen and deuterium are further removed from > each other than are Nickel and Palladium (or any two other transition > metals in the same column).**** > > ** ** > > Consider the H and D to be essentially *unrelated* insofar as Cooper > paring is concerned – this cannot happen with Deuterium in a hydride form. > However, the caveat is that the atomic form: deuteron with the electron > attached is a composite fermion – leaving open the door to the possibility > that a compact “deuterino” (a boson with an shrunken electron orbital, > giving a half integer net spin) can pair in the Cooper fashion, as a > preliminary step to cavity containment, for instance.**** > > ** ** > > Consider D and H to be as different, if not more different, than two > elements in the same column would be, in fact. **** >

