Pd-D has surprisingly little in common with Ni-H, in theory or in practice.
As far as most physical and especially nuclear properties are concerned, the fact that H and D are both chemically reactive volatile gases is the main connection. In fact, on close inspection, it is a big surprise to most observers that the two metals involved have more in common (physical properties) than do the gases D and H. In fact, nickel and palladium are in the same column (10) of the periodic table and are like two peas in a pod - as far as physical properties go. Cost is another issue. In Pd-D reactions, there is a bona fide nuclear reaction resulting in helium or tritium, plus the reactants are roughly 3 orders of magnitude more costly than Ni-H. The transmutation ash of Pd-D can be polluting (except for the helium); there is little that is renewable; transmutation is common, gamma radiation is seen, and the capital investment will be high. Most of all, Pd-D has never been scaled up to kilowatt level of output. In short, Pd-D is a comparative loser as far as ultimate commercialization is concerned. We have already seen in recent history the price of palladium will soar to astronomical highs, with only a slight change in supply. Little commercial opportunity exists for Pd-D, if and when Ni-H comes to market, and it does work for thermal gain. Fully replicated evidence goes back to the early nineties. Hydrogen is so completely different from deuterium that it can be considered a separate element, instead of an isotope. The periodic table which we have now, lumping the two together as isotopes, can be a bit arbitrary and misleading insofar as it leads to incorrect assumptions about many physical properties. The difference in physical and nuclear properties between the two (D and H) is staggering - far more pronounced than two elements in the same column of the periodic table, such as nickel and palladium, for instance. Jones (see footnote) From: James Bowery What I am talking about is the political economic miracle of an energy revolution. What we are being asked to believe here is that there is nothing in common between two revolutionary, non-polluting, virtually renewable, low capital investment energy production systems that both require hydrogen saturated metals (other than, of course, the fact that they both involve metals saturated with hydrogen). We're supposed to believe it is unreasonable to suspect such commonality because there are differences in the isotopes of hydrogen used in the two systems. FOOTNOTE: Premise: Palladium is far closer in physical and nuclear properties to Nickel, than deuterium is to hydrogen. The deuteron is a boson, not a fermion and does not obey Fermi-Dirac statistics. Hydrogen (the proton) is a fermion, and in contrast to all bosons like the deuteron, the proton does not obey Bose-Einstein statistics. It cannot occupy the same quantum state with another proton. The Pauli exclusion principle is the major difference between the two, wrt LENR - and it is precisely the factor which explains why deuterons will fuse easily, while protons will not fuse (outside of solar-like gravity). Plus there is far more mass difference between H and D than between Ni and Pd. Most other physical properties, are equally divergent. If you consider the bulk of physical properties including density, magnetic sensitivity, NMR receptivity, quadrupole moment, neutron capture cross-section etc, etc. Hydrogen and deuterium are further removed from each other than are Nickel and Palladium (or any two other transition metals in the same column). Consider the H and D to be essentially unrelated insofar as Cooper paring is concerned - this cannot happen with Deuterium in a hydride form. However, the caveat is that the atomic form: deuteron with the electron attached is a composite fermion - leaving open the door to the possibility that a compact "deuterino" (a boson with an shrunken electron orbital, giving a half integer net spin) can pair in the Cooper fashion, as a preliminary step to cavity containment, for instance. Consider D and H to be as different, if not more different, than two elements in the same column would be, in fact.

