Axil, I like a lot of your theory but think you are drawing too quickly your initial conclusion that no heat means no atomic hydrogen is being produced ..and even here we may be getting into syntax since atomic hydrogen once formed wants to immediately recombine.. and here is also my point that most disassociation and reassociation cycles are going to be almost instantaneous and the energy in to disassociate will normally be more than the energy released upon reassociation .. so the spark could very well be disassociating hydrogen which immediately reforms with little thermal indication for this.. a bootstrap requirement to set up the environment that your plasma theory or other over unity theories can multiply without an external source of energy -tapping some sort of zero point or LENR to keep the up the disassociation portion of the cycle while still releasing energy at the same rate on the reassociation portion of the cycle. Fran From: Axil Axil [mailto:janap...@gmail.com] Sent: Friday, December 28, 2012 1:41 AM To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Subject: EXTERNAL: Re: [Vo]:Papp and Water
"The recombination of atomic hydrogen to diatomic hydrogen is notoriously exothermic. Why, then, is it reported that the gas temperature rises little if at all" The fact that Russ has seen no heat produced by the spark discharge in hydrogen speaks to the fact that no atomic hydrogen is produced by the spark discharge. This is a clue to what is going on inside the gas medium. This insightful experimental observation supports the theory that accelerating plasmoid movement toward the head of the cylinder is the primary source of the power generated by the Papp reaction. If the plasmoid is the active power producing structure in the Papp engine, then it can concentrate a large number of electrons is high amperage circulating current flow concentrations at and around the outer surface of the plasmoid. As the plasmoid move through the uncharged dialectic gaseous medium(UDGM), The plasmoid must generate large numbers of negative charged clusters of gas atoms in the thin boundary zone between the plasmoids negative charged current layer and the UDGM. It is this contrail of residual negatively charged gas clusters that must be neutralized before the start of the next cycle can begin. This process of charge neutralization is how the feedback current is generated. The magnitude of this feedback current might be greater than the current that produced the spark discharge under certain noble gas mixtures. This increase in current can be one of the contributors to over unity power generation in the Papp reaction. This may also be the reason why the Papp engine exploded during the R. Feynman demo when an unchecked positive feedback current loop was formed between the various cylinders when the circuit that controlled the current feed to these cylinders was disabled. Increasing spark discharge current having been directly supported by the feedback current from other various cylinders produced a series of plasmoids of increasing strength. It was this uncontrolled current loop that eventually culminated in an explosive disintegration of the Papp engine after a few moments of unregulated operation when the control circuit was disabled after R. Feynman pulled the plug to the control unit. Cheers: Axil On Thu, Dec 27, 2012 at 8:42 PM, James Bowery <jabow...@gmail.com<mailto:jabow...@gmail.com>> wrote: The recombination of atomic hydrogen to diatomic hydrogen is notoriously exothermic. Why, then, is it reported that the gas temperature rises little if at all? On Thu, Dec 27, 2012 at 7:33 PM, David Roberson <dlrober...@aol.com<mailto:dlrober...@aol.com>> wrote: The discussion of Papp and his engine leads me to one question. Is it possible that the extra force that Russ, the video experimenter, obtained using hydrogen as the active gas was due to the dissociation of the hydrogen molecules into individual atoms? I suspect that the pressure must increase in such an environment due to the fact that there are more particles colliding. This may have been discussed previously, but the thought just came into my mind and I wanted to pass it on. Dave