> From: "Edmund Storms" <stor...@ix.netcom.com>
> Sent: Monday, May 20, 2013 8:09:29 AM
> Subject: Re: [Vo]:3rd Party Report Released

> Before we get too excited.  .... 

My biggest concern is with the resistive "blank" test. 

They should have done TWO blank runs

a) (Which they did) -- run the resistor at full power to bring it to a similar 
temperature.
b) Run the resistor with the same on-off cycle as the main run

Remarks section :

Their comparison of the shape of the heating/cooling curve with an RC 
resistor/capacitor circuit is WRONG because that assumes a linear resistor. But 
the radiation loss goes as T^4 --- I would be VERY surprised to see a shape 
like an RC exponential.

They should just have given the curves with no comparison.

Reply via email to