If someone is looking for an analogy they could look at the behavior of a power transistor mounted on a heat sink. For this exercise assume that the collector is directly connected to a power source. Apply enough base drive to obtain a relatively large collector current.
If you adjust the drive carefully you can reach a state of thermal run away within the transistor. Now, think of the run away condition as the region where Rossi operates his ECAT. Your job is to control the transistor collector temperature by modulating the base drive. You are constrained to operation at a temperature that exceeds the initial run away point with full drive applied. Carefully timed on - off drive to the transistor should be able to keep the temperature high, but limited. If you mess up and let the transistor get too hot, then the current will continue to increase out of control and burn it up. I have not done a careful analysis of this network, so I may have overlooked something about it behavior. The general idea is that I am asking you to perform a difficult job similar to what Rossi faces. Does this task look easy? Can you keep the temperature constant by any fixed drive level when the temperature of the transistor is above the first threshold? Positive feedback can be challenging. Dave -----Original Message----- From: Jed Rothwell <[email protected]> To: vortex-l <[email protected]> Sent: Thu, May 30, 2013 4:11 pm Subject: Re: [Vo]:Ethics of the E-Cat investigation put into question Joshua Cude <[email protected]> wrote: A match is needed to ignite a firecracker, but once ignited, the explosion sustains itself. A match is needed to start a campfire, but not to sustain it. Cold fusion is not fire. It does not work the same way. Evidently, Rossi's reactor requires external stimulation to keep the reaction under control. That's how it works. You cannot dictate to Mother Nature how things must work. If you unplug a Rossi cell and try to make it self-sustain without input, it will melt. An analogy to fire may be useful to understanding, but you cannot engineer a reactor based on analogies. - Jed

