A recent news item:

http://time.com/66459/portland-reservoir-pee/

"Portland Dumps 38 Million Gallons of Water After Man Pees in Reservoir

April 17, 2014

The city plans to dump 38 million gallons of water after authorities say a
19-year-old urinated in a large, uncovered reservoir during an early
morning jaunt with two other friends, even though the contamination likely
poses little risk . . ."

"Little risk" is incorrect. This poses absolutely no risk. Birds and other
animals defecate into reservoirs at a far higher rate than this.

This is an example of the kind of unscientific thinking that has dogged
society in recent years. I say it is OFF TOPIC in the title, but it is
actually somewhat on topic. Some of the resistance to cold fusion comes
from this kind of anti-science attitude.

Here is a comment about this I wrote on Slate:


This is an example of unscientific, irrational thinking. This is same kind
of nonsense that causes people to doubt the efficacy of vaccinations. The
city of Portland should resist doing this because it is not scientific and
there is absolutely no technical or medical justification for it. Officials
who understand science should not give in to mass hysteria based on
ignorance. That is a dangerous thing to do. In this case it merely wastes
water, energy and money. In other cases it may endanger the public.

Irrational fears cause decision makers to put far too much emphasis on some
preventive measures, which means they do not have the resources to deal
with other measures that would do more good.


- Jed

Reply via email to