Randy Bush пишет 04.08.2016 14:12:
My LIR have got ALLOCATED PI and ALLOCATED UNSPECIFIED blocks about
20 years ago, according to those days policy. Some part of address space
was not aggregated and was used as "ASSIGNED PI within ALLOCATED PI",
all of them have agreement with the LIR, which also was within the
policy, at least not against. Why should we change anything here? Just
because some LIRs lost their control over 50% of the address space
allocated to them? Perhaps there are some other ways to restore it?
After the LIRs have finished their research, the RIPE NCC will:
- Convert assignments to ASSIGNED PA if it can be documented that
the administrative responsibility lies with the LIR
- Follow up directly with resource holders of ASSIGNED PI to apply
the RIPE policy, “Contractual Requirements for Provider
Independent Resource Holders in the RIPE NCC Service Region”. The
PI assignments will become part of the address space managed by
the RIPE NCC just like all other PI space. Once the resource
holders have fulfilled the contractual requirements, they will
have the same rights and obligations as any other End User of PI
space.
- Split the allocations to separate the PI assignments and convert
the blocks that remain with an LIR to ALLOCATED PA.
i am perennially confused by the different colors of integers. as you
know, i prefer magenta and comic sans.
ingrid/ncc can you explain in terms an antique router geek can
understand what the actual pragmatic effect would be on these PI/PA
holders? does it alter holders' rights? costs? processes? ...
i suspect that you, larisa, already understand that. in this case, why,
in pragmatic terms a router geek can understand (yes, i know that's a
high bar, sorry), do you not like it?
randy
Hi Randy,
1. Manual update inetnums from ASSIGNED PI into ASSIGNED PA in two /16
blocks creates a lot of additional job for my LIR.
2. Lack of reasonable explanations for customers why this should be done.
That is why I'd prefer not to change anything here.
--
With respect,
*Larisa Yurkina*
RIPN
Internet Number Resources Group / Chief Manager
[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]> / www.ripn.net
<http://www.ripn.net>
Т.: +7 495 737-0604
