All of the major AI paradigms, including those that are capable of learning, are flat according to my definition. What makes them flat is that the method of decision making is minimally-structured and they funnel all reasoning through a single narrowly focused process that smushes different inputs to produce output that can appear reasonable in some cases but is really flat and lacks any structure for complex reasoning.
The classic example is of course logic. Every proposition can be described as being either True or False and any collection of propositions can be used in the derivation of a conclusion regardless of whether the input propositions had any significant relational structure that would actually have made it reasonable to draw the definitive conclusion that was drawn from them. But logic didn't do the trick, so along came neural networks and although the decision making is superficially distributed and can be thought of as being comprised of a structure of layer-like stages in some variations, the methodology of the system is really just as flat. Again anything can be dumped into the neural network and a single decision making process works on the input through a minimally-structured reasoning system and output is produced regardless of the lack of appropriate relative structure in it. In fact, this lack of discernment was seen as a major breakthrough! Surprise, neural networks did not work just like the mind works in spite of the years and years of hype-work that went into repeating this slogan in the 1980's. Then came Genetic Algorithms and finally we had a system that could truly learn to improve on its previous learning and how did it do this? It used another flat reasoning method whereby combinations of data components were processed according to one simple untiring method that was used over and over again regardless of any potential to see input as being structured in more ways than one. Is anyone else starting to discern a pattern here? Finally we reach the next century to find that the future of AI has already arrived and that future is probabilistic reasoning! And how is probabilistic reasoning different? Well, it can solve problems that logic, neural networks, genetic algorithms couldn't! And how does probabilistic reasoning do this? It uses a funnel minimally-structured method of reasoning whereby any input can be smushed together with other disparate input to produce a conclusion which is only limited by the human beings who strive to program it! The very allure of minimally-structured reasoning is that it works even in some cases where it shouldn't. It's the hip hooray and bally hoo of the smushababies of Flatway. Jim Bromer ------------------------------------------- agi Archives: https://www.listbox.com/member/archive/303/=now RSS Feed: https://www.listbox.com/member/archive/rss/303/ Modify Your Subscription: https://www.listbox.com/member/?member_id=8660244&id_secret=123753653-47f84b Powered by Listbox: http://www.listbox.com