I change my votes on 7943 and 7944. On 7943, I vote FOR. On 7944, AGAINST.
On Sat, Oct 28, 2017 at 9:26 PM, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus
<p.scribonius.scholasti...@gmail.com> wrote:
> I vote as follows:
>
>
> On 10/28/2017 02:27 AM, Aris Merchant wrote:
>> [Hopefully I've got everything right. The Proposal Pool will take a
>> few more days, and may even be a bit late. My apologies for any
>> inconvenience.]
>>
>> I hereby distribute each listed proposal, initiating the Agoran
>> Decision of whether to adopt it, and removing it from the proposal
>> pool. For this decision, the vote collector is the Assessor, the
>> quorum is 5.0 and the valid options are FOR and AGAINST (PRESENT is
>> also a valid vote).
>>
>> ID Author(s) AI Title Pender Pend fee
>> ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
>> 7931* G. 3.0 Registration fix finally G. 1 sh.
> FOR
>> 7932* ATMunn, [1] 1.0 A Reward for Obedience v5 ATMunn 1 AP
> FOR
>> 7933* Alexis 3.0 Ribbon Preservation Act Alexis 1 sh.
> FOR
>> 7934* 天火狐 1.0 Poetry Duel Challenge Writ 天火狐 OP [2]
> FOR
>> 7935* Trigon 3.0 Revision Limits v2 Trigon 1 AP
> AGAINST
>> 7936* V.J. Rada 2.0 Print Money V.J. Rada 1 AP
> FOR
>> 7937* V.J. Rada, o 2.0 I Demand Faster Auctions V.J. Rada 1 AP
> AGAINST
>> 7938* Aris 3.0 Fix Campaign Proposals Aris 1 AP
> FOR
>> 7939* V.J. Rada 1.0 Repeal the Reportor V.J. Rada 1 sh.
> AGAINST
>> 7940* Alexis, [3] 3.0 High Power Cleanup Alexis 1 sh.
> FOR
>> 7941* Alexis 1.0 HTML Scrubbing Alexis 1 sh.
> FOR
>> 7942* Alexis 1.0 No List Prefixes Alexis 1 sh.
> AGAINST
>> 7943* ATMunn 2.0 Mini fixes ATMunn 1 sh.
> FOR
>> 7944* Trigon 2.0 Who's the Secretary? Trigon 1 AP
> AGAINST, this would fail because the order is not specified.
>> 7945* Telnaior 1.0 Name and Shame Telnaior 1 AP
> FOR
>> 7946* Telnaior 3.0 MASUAC [4] Telnaior 1 AP
> FOR
>> 7947* V.J. Rada, [5] 3.0 MCVotA [6] V.J. Rada 2 sh.
> FOR
>> Legend: <ID>* : Proposal is pending.
>>
>> [1] Aris, Alexis, G.
>> [2] Official Proposal, inherently pending
>> [3] G., Publius Scribonius Scholasticus
>> [4] More Actions Should Use Agoran Consent
>> [5] Telnaior
>> [6] More Controversial Version of the Above
>>
>> A proposal may be pended for 1 AP, or for 1/20th the Floating Value
>> in shines (see the Treasuror's report).
>>
>> The full text of the aforementioned proposals is included below.
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 7931
>> Title: Registration fix finally
>> Adoption index: 3.0
>> Author: G.
>> Co-authors:
>>
>>
>> [It looks like we have various ways for players to make money now so
>> the re-registration bug can be fixed. Also clearly defines the verb
>> "to register" and makes it clear that registered persons can't "re"
>> register].
>>
>>
>> Amend Rule 869 (How to Join and Leave Agora) by replacing:
>>
>> Citizenship is a person switch with values Unregistered
>> (default) and Registered, tracked by the Registrar. Changes to
>> citizenship are secured. A registered person is a Player.
>>
>> A person CAN (unless explicitly forbidden or prevented by the
>> rules) register by publishing a message that indicates
>> reasonably clearly and reasonably unambiguously that e intends
>> to become a player at that time. A person, by registering,
>> agrees to abide by the Rules. The Rules CANNOT otherwise bind a
>> person to abide by any agreement without that person's willful
>> consent.
>>
>> A player CAN deregister (cease being a player) by announcement.
>> If e does so, e CANNOT register by announcement for 30 days.
>>
>> with:
>>
>> Citizenship is a person switch with values Unregistered
>> (default) and Registered, tracked by the Registrar. Changes to
>> citizenship are secured. A registered person is a Player.
>> To "register" someone is to flip that person's Citizenship
>> switch from Unregistered to Registered.
>>
>> An Unregistered person CAN (unless explicitly forbidden or
>> prevented by the rules) register by publishing a message that
>> indicates reasonably clearly and reasonably unambiguously that e
>> intends to become a player at that time. A player CAN deregister
>> (cease being a player) by announcement. If e does so, e CANNOT
>> register or be registered for 30 days.
>>
>> A person, by registering, agrees to abide by the Rules. The
>> Rules CANNOT otherwise bind a person to abide by any agreement
>> without that person's willful consent.
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 7932
>> Title: A Reward for Obedience v5
>> Adoption index: 1.0
>> Author: ATMunn
>> Co-authors: Aris, Alexis, G., V.J. Rada
>>
>>
>> Repeal rule 2482, "Victory Elections"
>>
>> Create a new power-1 rule titled "Medals of Honour"
>> {
>> Medals of Honour are a destructible fixed currency tracked by the Herald.
>>
>> In the 7 days of an Agoran month, any player CAN declare emself to be
>> eligible for a Medal of Honour by announcement if all of the following
>> are true:
>> * E has made at least 1 message to a public forum in the last Agoran
>> month.
>> * Eir Karma is not below -3.
>> * In the last Agoran month, e has not had a Card issued to em.
>>
>> In the first 7 days of an Agoran month after the first 7 days, if there
>> are any players who are eligible for a Medal of Honour, the Herald CAN,
>> by announcement, initiate an Agoran Decision on who is to be awarded a
>> Medal of Honour. E SHALL do so within the 7 days of an Agoran month after the
>> first 7 days. For this decision, the valid votes are all players who are
>> eligible for a Medal of Honour, the vote collector is the Herald, and the
>> voting
>> method is instant-runoff. Upon the resolution of this decision, the Herald
>> CAN,
>> and SHALL in a timely fashion, award the outcome of the decision a Medal of
>> Honour by announcement. After a player is awarded a Medal of Honour, all
>> players who were previously eligible for a Medal of Honour become no longer
>> eligible.
>>
>> If, at any time, any player has 6 or more Medals of Honour, and e has
>> not won via this rule previously, e can win the game by announcement,
>> destroying all of eir Medals of Honour.
>> }
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 7933
>> Title: Ribbon Preservation Act
>> Adoption index: 3.0
>> Author: Alexis
>> Co-authors:
>>
>> Amend rule 2438 by appending the following to the second paragraph:
>>
>> "If the rules are amended to change the types of Ribbon, if a player's Ribbon
>> Ownership is subsequently illegal, then it is updated by removing all
>> nonexistent types rather than resetting the entire value to default."
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 7934
>> Title: Poetry Duel Challenge Writ
>> Adoption index: 1.0
>> Author: 天火狐
>> Co-authors:
>> SILY PROPOSAL; OFFICIAL PROPOSAL
>>
>>
>> A player CAN issue the title's writ
>> once a month to another, who
>> this month a different writ they yet remit,
>> by having the first player pays its due
>> of ten shinies and announces intent.
>> If a party remits, they are disgraced;
>> else the pair must to the public present
>> a poem each which then Agorans be faced
>> with a Decision of which one is better.
>> Each task a timely manner it be done,
>> The winner gains the loser as debtor,
>> of whose function this rule shall provide none.
>> The text above contitues a new rule
>> whose title matches this proposal's; cool?
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 7935
>> Title: Revision Limits v2
>> Adoption index: 3.0
>> Author: Trigon
>> Co-authors:
>>
>>
>> Amend Rule 2201 "Self-Ratification" by removing the second paragraph and
>> list.
>>
>> Create a new rule with power 3 entitled "Doubt" with the following text:
>>
>> A doubt is an explicit public challenge via one of the following
>> methods, identifying a document and explaining the scope and
>> nature of a perceived error in it:
>>
>> 1. An inquiry case, appropriate for questions of legal
>> interpretation.
>>
>> 2. A claim of error, appropriate for matters of fact. The
>> publisher of the original document SHALL (if e was required to
>> publish that document) or SHOULD (otherwise) do one of the
>> following in a timely fashion:
>> A. Deny the claim (causing it to cease to be a doubt).
>> B. Publish a revision.
>> C. Initiate an inquiry case regarding the truth of the claim
>> (if the subject is actually a matter of law), or cite a
>> relevant existing inquiry case.
>>
>> Create a new rule with power 3 entitled "The Revision Limit" with the
>> following
>> text:
>>
>> The Revision Limit is an untracked natural singleton switch
>> defaulting to 2 that CAN be set by any player without objection.
>>
>> If a report has had a number of revisions published to it greater
>> than the revision limit, efforts by the player that published the
>> report to collect a reward on eir next report are INEFFECTIVE.
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 7936
>> Title: Print Money
>> Adoption index: 2.0
>> Author: V.J. Rada
>> Co-authors:
>>
>>
>> Amend rule 2487 "Shiny Supply Level" by replacing the number "1000"
>> with the text "equal to 70 times the number of players" and by
>> replacing "may" with "CAN and SHALL" and replacing "without 3
>> Objections" to "once per Agoran month, in the first Agoran week of
>> that month"
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 7937
>> Title: I Demand Faster Auctions
>> Adoption index: 2.0
>> Author: V.J. Rada
>> Co-authors: o
>>
>>
>> In rule 2491, replace "At the start of each month" with "At the
>> start of each week"
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 7938
>> Title: Fix Campaign Proposals
>> Adoption index: 3.0
>> Author: Aris
>> Co-authors: Ørjan
>>
>>
>> Change the power of the rule entitled "Campaign Proposals, with power 3"
>> to 3.0.
>>
>> Retitle the rule "Campaign Proposals, with power 3" to "Campaign Proposals".
>>
>> Amend the rule "Campaign Proposals" by replacing "and SHALL NOT be
>> distributed as required by the rules" with "and SHALL NOT be distributed
>> except as required by the rules".
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 7939
>> Title: Repeal the Reportor
>> Adoption index: 1.0
>> Author: V.J. Rada
>> Co-authors:
>>
>>
>> Repeal rule 2446 "The Agoran Newspaper"
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 7940
>> Title: High Power Cleanup
>> Adoption index: 3.0
>> Author: Alexis
>> Co-authors: G., Publius Scribonius Scholasticus
>>
>>
>> Text in square brackets is not a substantive part of this proposal and is
>> ignored when it takes effect.
>>
>> Amend Rule 105, bullet 2 to read "When a rule is repealed, it ceases
>> to be a rule,
>> its power is set to 0, and the Rulekeepor need no longer maintain a record
>> of it."
>>
>> [There is a ruling that repealed rules have their power set to 0, but I'm
>> not sure I fully agree with that conclusion; this makes it explicit which
>> can't hurt anyway.]
>>
>> Amend Rule 106 by appending "Except insofar as the actions performed by a
>> proposal happen one after another, rather than simultaneously, a proposal's
>> effect is instantaneous. A proposal can neither delay nor extend its own
>> effect. Once a propsal finishes taking effect, its power is set to 0."
>>
>> [Per discussion, do the same for proposals. While here, make it clear that
>> proposals are instantaneous. Please nitpick this, I'm pretty sure it's safe
>> but this is a very dangerous rule to get wrong.]
>>
>> Set the power of all entities other than Rules, Regulations, and this
>> Proposal to 0. If rule 2493 was repealed, or the word "instrument" does not
>> appear in its text, also set the power of all Regulations to 0.
>>
>> [This is a general cleanup that catches repealed rules and other entities.]
>>
>> Amend Rule 105, bullet 3 by appending "Unless specified otherwise by the
>> re-enacting instrument, a re-enacted rule has power equal to the power it
>> had at the time of its repeal (or power 1, if power was not defined at the
>> time of that rule's repeal). If the re-enacting instrument is incapable of
>> setting the re-enacted rule's power to that value, then the re-enactment is
>> null and void."
>>
>> [Re-enactment currently doesn't have a specified power; this causes it to
>> work roughly the way you would expect it to.]
>>
>> Amend Rule 1023 by appending "The same applies, mutatis mutandis, to for
>> determining whether two points in time are within N months of each other,
>> for N greater than or equal to 2." as a new paragraph in the fourth bullet
>> in the first list.
>>
>> [This makes the logical extension to "within 6 months", which is used,
>> explicit.]
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 7941
>> Title: HTML Scrubbing
>> Adoption index: 1.0
>> Author: V.J. Rada
>> Co-authors:
>>
>>
>> The Distributor is hereby requested to enable the Mailman feature(s) to
>> strip non-plain-text parts of emails sent by the agoranomic.org mailing
>> lists.
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 7942
>> Title: No List Prefixes
>> Adoption index: 1.0
>> Author: V.J. Rada
>> Co-authors:
>>
>>
>> The Distributor is hereby requested to disable the DIS, BUS, and OFF
>> prefixes automatically added to mail sent by the agoranomic.org mailing
>> lists.
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 7943
>> Title: Mini fixes
>> Adoption index: 2.0
>> Author: ATMunn
>> Co-authors:
>>
>>
>> Amend rule 2514, "Emotions", by replacing "registrar" with "Registrar"
>>
>> Amend rule 1650, "Silliness", by replacing "Each Nomic Week" with
>> "Each Agoran week"
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 7944
>> Title: Who's the Secretary?
>> Adoption index: 2.0
>> Author: Trigon
>> Co-authors:
>>
>>
>> Replace all instances of the word "Secretary" in rule 2516: Passive Income
>> with the word "Treasuror"
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 7945
>> Title: Name and Shame
>> Adoption index: 1.0
>> Author: Telnaior
>> Co-authors:
>>
>>
>> Amend Rule 2168 ("Extending the voting period", power 1) thus:
>> Modify the string
>> "the vote collector for the decision SHALL issue a
>> humiliating public reminder to the slackers who have not yet cast any
>> votes on it despite being eligible"
>> to
>> "the vote collector for the decision SHALL issue a humiliating public
>> reminder naming the slackers who have not yet cast any votes on it
>> despite being eligible"
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 7946
>> Title: More Actions Should Use Agoran Consent
>> Adoption index: 3.0
>> Author: Telnaior
>> Co-authors:
>>
>>
>> Flip the Citizenship switch of Ienpw III to Unregistered.
>> Flip the Citizenship switch of Bayushi to Unregistered.
>> Flip the Citizenship switch of ProofTechnique to Unregistered.
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>> ID: 7947
>> Title: More Controversial Version of the Above
>> Adoption index: 3.0
>> Author: V.J. Rada
>> Co-authors: Telnaior
>>
>>
>> Deregister Murphy unless e objects during the voting period for this proposal
>> and deregister omd unless e objects during the voting period for this
>> proposal
>>
>> //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
>
>
--
>From V.J. Rada
