I don't find a "waveform" (amplitude vs. time) display difficult to interpret. Over modulation in the negative direction shows up clearly as "pearls" on the baseline and positive peak levels can be easily read by slowing down the trace. Flat-toping can be clearly seen at higher sweep speeds. Admittedly, a trapezoid display can provide additional information but I've never found it worth the trouble.

I find the trapezoid useful for determining peak positive and negative modulation percentage, since it is a little easier to interpret that looking at the modulated waveform. But it tells nothing about the waveform of the modulating signal. A severely distorted flat-topped signal looks almost identical to a pure sinewave.

The trapezoid is most useful for observing the modulation linearity of the final. I have one of my transmitters set up where I can instantly switch from one to the other.

One problem with the trapezoid is if you use it a lot, it will burn a vertical line on the face of the scope tube, since it displays a bright vertical line whenever there is no modulation.

On envelope pattern, I have a relay to kick in bias voltage to deflect the patter off the screen when not transmitting. Leaving the horizontal base line on all the time will burn a horizontal line into the face of the scope tube.

Don K4KYV


Reply via email to