yes Dil ka rishta can be called pathbreaking! it had western classical tune + hindustani aalap combo, a never before heard feel (at least i felt so). the song was about 3 different personalities coming together/singing together.
may be the average public found this song to be too heavy or not understandable. thats ok. but i was surprised why many critics & reviewers ignored this song. may be its above their level On Wed, Dec 24, 2008 at 10:47 AM, Nagaraj <arr_naga...@yahoo.com> wrote: > Shocked to see nobody speaking abt Dil Ka Rishta which i felt was > path breaking.. > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, > "divyaishu" <divyai...@...> > wrote: > > > > > I am surprised at the interviewer. Actually Yuvvraaj songs weren't > > all that bad to be declared "lost with the movie". If I had to > speak > > of myself I liked all the songs except Mastam. And as a generic > > statement, people loved Dost and Tu Muskura, that is to say > atleast 2 > > songs in the album that the average audiences might want to hum > > repeatedly. > > > > Sonu Nigam says the songs weren't promoted well. I think it was > poor > > picturization. Shano Shano must have had a great choreography. > When I > > first heard the song, I thought it must have had some incredibly > fast > > dance sequences, unlike what was portrayed. But when one still > > reverts to the audio version, it does sound different, it sounds > foot- > > tapping, sounds just apt for a dance floor, buddy! (And you > wouldn't > > expect this sort of thumping outcome from any composer other than > ARR > > for a song like Shano!) > > > > The bottomline: a poor presentation by Subhash Ghai. > > > > Divya > > > > > > > > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, > "Gomzy™" <gomtesh.upadhye@> > > wrote: > > > > > > http://specials.rediff.com/movies/2008/dec/22video1-sonu-sings- > for- > > rediff.htm > > > > > > > > > Excerpts > > > > > > *How did the industry people react to this change in you?* > > > > > > People, who wanted to work with me, were obviously disturbed by > my > > > unavailability. Others were rejoicing as they were getting more > > work. I > > > don't have to worry about how people reacted. I need to worry > about > > myself > > > and my contribution to the industry. > > > > > > Honestly, when people hear too much of you, they stop > appreciating > > your > > > work. On the other hand, when they get less of you, they start > > missing you. > > > For example, I just hummed a part in *Guzarish* from > > > *Ghajini*<http://www.rediff.com/movies/ghajini08.html>. > > > I haven't sung the song. But the kind of reviews I got just for > my > > humming > > > is amazing. And this is because they have not been hearing > enough > > of me. If > > > they had heard me through the songs of *Ghajini*, they wouldn't > > have spoken > > > about my humming. > > > > > > > > > *Is it true that you had sung Guzarish a long time ago?* > > > > > > Yes. I sang the song about two and a half years ago, with > different > > lyrics. > > > When they changed the lyrics and asked me to sing, I wasn't > > available. I was > > > in New Jersey for my son's birth. > > > > > > So they called Javed Ali and I think he has done an awesome job. > > The song > > > became his. But out of respect for me, A R Rahman kept the > humming > > part > > > intact. > > > > > > *Did that upset you?* > > > > > > No. If I was an insecure person, it would have. It was meant to > be > > Javed's > > > song, and so it is. Everybody has the right to earn their bread > and > > butter. > > > There is no point cribbing about something that was not meant > for > > you. > > > > > > *What do you think went wrong with Yuvvraaj's music? Why, do you > > think, the > > > film and music did not do well?* > > > > > > *Yuvvraaj* had great songs. My favourite was *Dost*. I wish I > was > > given that > > > song to sing. I sang three songs from the film. I think they > were > > not > > > promoted well. If they were, things would have been different. > > > > > > *Mastam Mastam* came out when the film released and since the > film > > didn't do > > > well, the song got lost. *Dil Ka Sikka* is out now, and the film > is > > out of > > > theatres. A lot depends on the fate of the film. If it is > promoted > > well, it > > > would have done well -- like *Nagada* from *Jab We Met*. > > > > > > > >
