Hi Carey,
That sounds very promising.
One problem with the XML-definitions is their bulk. I doubt that it will
be possible to to use XML-definitions for example on the whole
ITSM7-application...
The output from ARInside is not customizable, but is very good. It is not
open source, and I do not know how much work Stefan Nerlich currently puts
into the project...
I would encourage you to take a look at the output from ARInside. I can
make some sample ARInside-output available for you if you like.
Best Regards - Misi, RRR AB, http://rrr.se
> Mark,
>
> That is actually a tool that I have not spent any time with. So I can
> not compare them directly.
>
> Yes both are documentation tools for ARS. ( And there are several
> commercial products too.)
>
> However... a little more detail on my stuff is simply this...
>
> The output is totally controlled by XSLT transformations. So if a
> person knows XSLT (or can read the existing stack of them and tweak
> them) then they could change the output to what ever they want it to
> do. Currently it generates HTML/Javascript for browser consumption,
> but I can also see it being specialized into CSV file generators very
> easily.
>
> So if ARInside offers that same "simple" total customization approach
> then I guess it does do the "same things". But I doubt it is as
> flexible as the approach that I am taking.
>
> I have found my tool helpful for many things over the years, but it is
> not (by any other hands than mine) polished into a final form. So it
> "works" as much as it does, but it is not "tested" on a larger scale
> than my desktops too.
>
> FWIW: Ok.. I just went out and found a copy of ARInside out there in
> the internet (version ARInside-Setup-2-07-2.msi to be exact) and I
> remember why I have not used ARInside before. It requires the ".Net
> Framework v2.x" and I do not load that on any of my PC's. So it is a
> "no go" as far as I am concerned at that point. Which is why I have
> never used it.
>
> However even at that a quick review of the 10 page pdf docs that is
> included in that version tells me a few things are different in our
> approaches...
>
> ARInside: Command line utility that appears to produce a set of
> "output fies" that are all generated at run time.
> my web app: Web server based: produces one output "page" at a time. (
> currently no "batch generate all" pages option)
>
> ARInside: uses ARS API
> my web app: Only parses XML into output formats (at this time, no API
> requirements, so in theory you could put this web application on a MAC
> based web server and make it work too.)
>
> And I am sure there are other differences too... ( like maybe ARInside
> is faster, or has better documentation, better output, or...etc...)
>
> So again... if anyone is interested let me know if you want to know
> more about "my web app". (Which by the way I currently refer to
> "arsxml" because I could not come up with a better name than that. :)
>
> Oh.. and did I mention that my intention was to be open sourced with
> this project from day one? :) [ Again... like ARSDocs ]
>
>
> The shortest explanation is "ARSDocs but: using Java instead of Perl,
> and reduce time from "need information to result outputs". (and
> totally based on open standards/needs, and "easily"(and totally)
> customizable without "programming" skills. Well, limited to XSLT
> skills.)
>
> --
> Carey Matthew Black
> Remedy Skilled Professional (RSP)
> ARS = Action Request System(Remedy)
>
> Love, then teach
> Solution = People + Process + Tools
> Fast, Accurate, Cheap.... Pick two.
>
>
> On Jan 11, 2008 7:20 AM, Mark Rushton <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>> **
>> Isn't this what ArInside does?
>>
>>
>>
>> Mark Rushton
>> IBM Global Services
>> Remedy Engineering & Development Team
>>
>>
>> Carey Matthew Black <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
>> Sent by: "Action Request System discussion list(ARSList)"
>> <[email protected]>
>>
>> 11/01/2008 11:50
>>
>> Please respond to
>> [email protected]
>>
>>
>> To [email protected]
>>
>> cc
>>
>>
>> Subject Re: How to Document Workflow?
>>
>>
>>
>> Brian,
>>
>> I have not spoke much about this... and if there were interest I guess
>> that could change....
>>
>> I started a project a few years ago with the following goals:
>>
>> 1) Do what ARSDocs does, but without the hours of processing time it
>> takes between "Oh I need to know" and "Ding. Your files are built."
>> 2) Do what ARSDocs does, but not use ARSPerl
>> 3) Do what ARSDocs does, but be more customizable to the end user
>> without "programming knowledge"
>>
>> I got stuck with my approach do to some technical bumps that I have
>> not had time to fix, but it works.
>>
>> Long story short....
>>
>> I put together a JSP/Servlet based web application that takes an ARS
>> XML def file and produces lists/pages of the details of the objects. I
>> can not say that the application is "easy to setup", or that it is
>> more than at an alpha stage... but if anyone is interested... I think
>> I could find a place to publish it and give you a shot at helping me
>> figure out what needs fixed first. Mostly performance issues with
>> parsing XML. :) It should work on any Mid-Tier compatible web server,
>> but currently does not use any BMC API code. Maybe some day it will,
>> but not yet.
>>
>> As a quick idea of what it can do.... For a given XML file...
>>
>> Objects All
>> Forms
>> Form_Permissions
>> Views
>> Fields
>> Active Links
>> Filters
>> Escalations
>> Containers
>> Menus
>> Actions All
>> only_ActiveLinks
>> only_Macros
>> only_Filters
>> only_Escalations
>> only_Messages
>> only_Notifications
>> only_RunProcess
>>
>> Hide/show based on (Enabled/Disabled/Both) objects in all lists.
>> Link from a field in a Set field action to all other workflow that
>> references that field. (According to the XML file that is being
>> processed.)
>>
>> Then each of those "list pages" has links to other detail pages... and
>> so on .. and so on...
>>
>> Note: Their are likely v6.3 and v7.1 XML changes that need to be
>> adjusted for still, but I started this in v5.1.2 so that should be no
>> surprise. :)
>>
>> A word of caution... I doubt this will work with large ARS
>> applications. ( The xml file is just to big to process exactly this
>> way. Your Servlet container settings may need to be adjusted (max ram
>> = 5 x <size of largest XML file you want to parse> appears to be a
>> good starting point.) So YMMV.
>>
>>
>> But if there is interest I think I could publish it and see if anyone
>> out there would be willing to help improve it too. (The offer/request
>> for help is not limited to Brian.)
>>
>> --
>> Carey Matthew Black
>> Remedy Skilled Professional (RSP)
>> ARS = Action Request System(Remedy)
>>
>> Love, then teach
>> Solution = People + Process + Tools
>> Fast, Accurate, Cheap.... Pick two.
>
> _______________________________________________________________________________
> UNSUBSCRIBE or access ARSlist Archives at www.arslist.org
> Platinum Sponsor: www.rmsportal.com ARSlist: "Where the Answers Are"
>
> --
> This message was scanned by ESVA and is believed to be clean.
>
_______________________________________________________________________________
UNSUBSCRIBE or access ARSlist Archives at www.arslist.org
Platinum Sponsor: www.rmsportal.com ARSlist: "Where the Answers Are"