* Gary Denton ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote:

> About $100 billion a year would be freed up for stocks, bonds and
> other investments under a tentative plan President Bush has floated
> to fix the Social Security retirement system by creating private
> investment accounts.
>
> The fees paid to brokers and money managers could run into the
> billions.

They could, if the privatisation is implemented poorly, i.e., as an
actively managed mutual-fund type account. But that would be stupid. You
are arguing against a good idea based on a stupid implementation of it.
If you want to accomplish something, it is more effective to argue FOR
an intelligent implementation of a good idea:

The annual fee for an index fund is about 0.1%. So, 0.1% of $100B is
$100M. In actuality, it will be lower, since such a large account will
be able to get economies of scale. Very large pension funds currently
can get 0.05%.

--
Erik Reuter   http://www.erikreuter.net/
_______________________________________________
http://www.mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l

Reply via email to