Jerry B. Altzman wrote:

(aside to Mikel: your formatting and gmail don't play nicely together...)


This is weird cause I've selected plain text (not even both) for the formatting and now this is the second time someone is mentioning, this.




Why "cheapen" a cert by having something that is basically wallpaper?
Is there an MS "user" cert? (I don't know.)
Ask yourself: what is this *for*? What do I want to *certify*? Who would care?


True but to be a standard windows user you don't need to know any cli. As I said it's a nice to have certainly not a requirement.

The whole reason I drafted this concept was to ultimately reduce the work
load drafting up these certs. Since the first block will be slow to change
it should require the lowest amount of effort to maintain once established.
This should also in turn free up people who are say experts in security or
db stuff to maintain these fast paced areas of expertise. This could also
help to reduce the duplication of effort and overlap.




Well, instead, let's think of ourselves of consumers of the certified.
If someone has a 'basic' level cert, what the heck are we expecting
them to know? Installation? Package management?
If I came to you and said I was "Jr. BSD Admin", how much leeway would
you give me?
What questions should I skip in the interview? What should I expect
you to know coming in right away?

I'm kinda harping on the semantics of this, since precious few certs
carry any real weight. (The CCIE is an exception, as are, for example,
the actuarial exams and subsequent chartering).



While I do agree that there are too many water soluble certs out there which is why I tend to not put much faith in any vendor specified cert.

No I don't think so, but that is some thing that would set these apart from
vendor specific certs. If the jr passes the test why not? Of course this all
depends upon how the certs are defined. I am just tossing out one scenario.



I'm just tossing out a criticism of it, and making an alternative
suggestion: no additional certs can be piled on a junior BSD cert.


We are talking about core competencies here. Neither the Jr nor Sr admin would be a CCIE level on it's own. But with the appropriate addons they could be I guess. I mean differences between the two could probably be things like kernel patching and compiling, disk geometry and things like that...



I don't see any reason why not. When I was in the
military I held many advance certifications at a jr level. For instance an
E4 Electronics Technician could hold a Crypto Cert, that his E10 ETCS
supervisor does not. The Senior Chief is clearly a top level cert he
certainly gets paid enough, but he doesn't need to be certified on the
crypto equipment to manage those who are and work on it daily. Does it mean
that he couldn't work on said equipment if the need arose? Of course he
could, that's what tech manuals are for.



Granted, but those are somewhat independent certs, no? I mean, we're talking about "advanced such-and-such ON BSD" -- there's nothing that says a Jr. BSD sysadmin couldn't also get his OCP, or CCIE, or CISSP...



-- Cheers, Mikel King Optimized Computer Solutions, INC 39 West Fourteenth



//jbaltz



-- Cheers, Mikel King Optimized Computer Solutions, INC 39 West Fourteenth Street Second Floor New York, NY 10011 http://www.ocsny.com t:212.727.2100x132

+------------------------------------------+
You may like them. You will see. You may
like them in a tree.
http://www.FreeBSD.org
http://www.OpenOffice.org
http://www.Mozilla.org
+------------------------------------------+
How do you spell cooperation? Pessimists use
each other, but optimists help each other.
Collaboration feeds your spirit, while
competition only stokes your ego. You'll
find the best way to get along.
+------------------------------------------+

begin:vcard
fn:Mikel King
n:King;Mikel
org:Optimized Computer Solutions, INC.;Engineering
adr:Second Floor #203;;39 West Fourteenth Street;New York;NY;10011;US
email;internet:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
title:CIO/CTO
tel;work:212.727.2100x132
tel;fax:212.463.8402
tel;cell:646.554.3660
x-mozilla-html:TRUE
url:http://www.ocsny.com
version:2.1
end:vcard

_______________________________________________
BSDcert mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.nycbug.org/mailman/listinfo/bsdcert

Reply via email to