Hello Charles, With due respect I ask, why did you abandon your quest for the CCIE? I am curious as to how many times you actually hit the Lab?
Sincerely, CN >From: "Charles Riley" >Reply-To: "Charles Riley" >To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] >Subject: Re: CCIE Lab - I have seen he future and it is.... [7:62776] >Date: Mon, 10 Feb 2003 22:19:54 GMT > >Chuck, > >Your post reminds me of those weird little ice cream stands that I sometimes >see at the mall and various carnivals. It's called something like "Dipping >Dots - The Ice Cream of the Future". The initial human instinct is much >like the Cro-Magnon humanoids encountering the monolith at the beginning of >2001: A Space Odyssey (sp): jump up and down with excitement until you >realize it's just freeze dried ice cream. > >Rounding out that analogy, the CCIE of the future will probably be reduced >to being the CCNP of today. Regardless, I have spent too much time and >money to abandon the quest for CCIE now, but frankly, if I hadn't invested >as much as I have, I would most likely abandon the quest in favor of >broadening into other areas. I really don't see much market value for the >CCIE anymore, especially with Cisco hellbent on making it a meatgrinding >cash cow. Your java console and "one way only to configure" experience kind >of bears this out. > >Sorry for the depressing post, just wanted to share. > >Charles > > > > > >""The Long and Winding Road"" wrote in >message [EMAIL PROTECTED]">news:[EMAIL PROTECTED]... > > Been spending this weekend on what was once the Cisco Advanced SE Training > > ( ASET ) set of labs. These are available for those whose Cisco account >team > > approves - there are a few conditions which can be found in the wee places > > of certification training. > > > > The program is run by Lab Gear ( the only link I have is www.labgear.net, > > but > > this is a login page ) There are a number of labs of CCIE level, look, and > > feel. > > > > Supposed to be real equipment, but the access is via java script windows, > > not terminal emulation. This makes for some interesting situations. The > > windows show or provide output only when they are active. So if you had >two > > router sessions open, and you made changes on one router that would >generate > > systems messages of one sort or another you would not see those messages >on > > the other. also, I have yet to find a way to generate output from >debugging > > commands. Things like term mon and logging of one kind or another have not > > been successful. so no debug ip routing and debug ip ospf adj. > > > > As with the real lab, there are a series of tasks to be completed. Grading > > is done via a script. This is the point of most interest. Actually, I > > suspect a lot of the current CCIE Lab grading is done using scripting >tools. > > I believe the proctors still physically examine equipment configurations >for > > some things, but I could be wrong. > > > > It is of interest because to judge from the script outputs I am seeing, > > there appears to be an assumption that there is one and only one way to do > > things. I'm not sure this is always true. I am not sure that this results >in > > an entirely accurate grade. > > > > But more importantly, given my experience with the java consoles and the > > manner in which these labs must be done, I am not sure I like where this >is > > headed. Something Brian Dennis and Brad Ellis and some other people >started > > talking about back when the CCIE Lab went from two days to one - something > > about the longer term goal being to do the test remotely, and having >people > > show up at Sylvan or some other testing center and log in remotely. > > > > If the Lab Gear approach is any indication, this is not ready for real >live > > testing. I experienced far too many problems with terminal ( javascript ) > > sessions disconnecting mysteriously. With 8 open windows, it sometimes got > > to be very hard to find the session ( router ) I was looking for. Cut and > > paste is a real pain. You have to open a "scratchpad" window, which is > > associated with the javascript console window. cutting and pasting is done > > to this wind. there are scratchpad windows associated with each java wind, > > so if you had a scratchpad open for every router session, that makes for a > > LOT of junk to fight your way through looking for what you want. then >there > > is the problem of actually moving what you want to copy and paste. >highlight > > and control c control v or alt e paste don't work. you have to click on > > buttons on the java consoles to copy to and from routers. > > > > beyond that, there is the problems of whether or not the "script" answer >is > > the right answer. For example, in one lab, a particular instruction >requires > > that the rip routers on a particular segment have to use the neighbor > > statement to see eachother ( and prevent other routers on that segment >from > > joining into the RIP domain ) well, the problem is, one of those routers >is > > connected to another RIP router via a different interface. need a neighbor > > statement there too, but the script does not cover this, nor does the >answer > > configuration show this. > > > > anyway, I have seen the future, and the CCIE Lab future looks like it may >be > > heading to these kinds of remote lab settings. > > > > -- > > TANSTAAFL > > "there ain't no such thing as a free lunch" > > > > misconduct and Nondisclosure violations to [EMAIL PROTECTED] ------------------------------------------------------------------------ MSN 8 helps ELIMINATE E-MAIL VIRUSES. Get 2 months FREE*. Message Posted at: http://www.groupstudy.com/form/read.php?f=7&i=62803&t=62776 -------------------------------------------------- FAQ, list archives, and subscription info: http://www.groupstudy.com/list/cisco.html Report misconduct and Nondisclosure violations to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
