I have the same feeling with the swipe-up gesture in the task manager: it's not smooth.

Moreover, I still have great difficulties to do this gesture. The vertical swipe is too precise to do at first try. Is it possible to decide that the swipe is vertical when the vertical move of the swipe is greater than the horizontal one ? It would mean that any swipe at an angle > 45° from the horizontal will be detected as vertical, which is exactly what I would expect.

Augustin Trancart
Phoxygen

On 26/11/2015 12:50, Christopher Lord wrote:
My pet peeve at the moment has to be edge swipes:

- The performance is terrible
- When they're enabled, events on the edge of apps when not swiping are delivered twice (this includes for the home gesture - try switching tabs in the Dialer with that enabled) - The UX means it's practically impossible to know what apps are actually going to appear (the stack keeps getting reordered) - You can't tell what app you're swiping to until it's very far onto the screen

Since disabling them and using Michael's button-bar add-on, my experience with the device has massively improved. I can use the edges of the screen again (so YouTube and Facebook's like buttons are now usable without having to press them several times in the hope that you can trigger an odd number of click events, and games that use the edge of the screen work correctly) and I can quickly close the current app (which I find is a much more useful action than edge swiping) and quickly bring up the task manager (so I easily see what apps there are in the stack without committing to switching to one first).

I actually find the UX of Michael's button-bar superior to edge gestures and would rather it be included and edge-gestures removed entirely... But failing that, fixing the performance and somehow making the order of the stack more obvious/consistent would be good.

--Chris

On 24 November 2015 at 17:58, Sam Foster <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:

    As we get started on 2.6, it would be good to hear more about how
    the UI facilities the system app provides are meeting
    requirements. If you have pet peeves, long standing issues, future
    thoughts  - lets get them captured. I know we have many bugs
    already in bugzilla (and we'll try to winnow them down) but some
    are old enough its hard to know if they are still relevant. Also
    we have ideas being generated by the Alopex initiative. But as
    developers writing apps on this platform - and dogfooders - what
    do you think needs improving?

    Potential topics:
    * Lock screen
    * Utility tray,
    * Toasters and notifications
    * Edge swipe
    * Task Manager
    * App transitions
    * Window management
    * Status bar
    * Dialogs
    * App chrome


    Does the way the apps/content interact with the system make sense
    and meet all your present needs?

    thanks,
    /Sam



    _______________________________________________
    dev-fxos mailing list
    [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>
    https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-fxos




_______________________________________________
dev-fxos mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-fxos

_______________________________________________
dev-fxos mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-fxos

Reply via email to