On 7/28/2017 6:34 AM, Alex Gaynor wrote: > Frankly I was surprised to see Chromium reverse course on this -- they have > a history of aggressive leadership in their handling of CA failures, it's a > little disappointing to see them abandon that. > > I'd strongly advocate for us perusing an earlier date -- December 1st at > the latest. Reasons: > > 1) Chromium's stated reason for avoiding dates around the holidays makes no > sense -- organizations with change freezes they need to adhere to have a > simple solution: obtain and deploy a new certificate at an earlier date! > They have 4 months between now and December 1st, if you can't deploy a cert > in 4 months, I submit you have larger problems. > > 2) It is important that CAs not be rewarded for the length of time this > process takes. CAs should be encouraged and rewarded for active > participation and engagement in this list. > > 3) Mandatory CT (well, mandatory for trust in Chromium) is a significant > win for security and transparency. At the moment, even discussing the > parameters of the distrust is complicated by the fact that we have limited > visibility into the iceberg of their PKI before June 1st, 2016 (see the > other thread where I attempt to discuss the count they provide of > outstanding certs that would be impacted). Given the challenges we know > exist in their legacy PKI, I think it's fair to say that continuing to > trust these certs represents real risk for our users's security. > > Alex
I strongly agree. The focus must be on protecting end-users, not on Symantec or on Symantec's customers. Symantec must know who has subscriber certificates that chain to Symantec's roots. Those customers could all be notified very quickly that their certificates are about to be distrusted. Those customers would then have ample time to obtain and install replacement subscriber certificates chaining to alternative roots of other certification authorities. As for any disruption of secure transactions, consider the abrupt termination of DigiNotar when that certification authority was found to have serious lapses in its operations. The world did not end. -- David E. Ross <http://www.rossde.com/>. The only reason we have so many laws is that not enough people will do the right thing. (© 1997 by David Ross) _______________________________________________ dev-security-policy mailing list [email protected] https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-security-policy

