On Jun 19, 11:59 am, "L. David Baron" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> Only because Gecko provides APIs for the purpose of helping
> applications 
> followhttp://www.mozilla.org/build/revised-user-agent-strings.html

Which we are doing.

> > it has absolutely
> > no direct effect on any other product or shared component,
>
> It most certainly does, since it increases the pressure on other
> non-Firefox Gecko apps to make the same change.

I used the word "direct" very deliberately. That's an indirect effect,
and all kinds of things have indirect effects on other browsers. As a
concrete example, we get pressure from some users to implement things
like middle-click-to-close-tabs because of Firefox having done it, but
I don't think that means that I should be able to override mconnor
when I disagree with Firefox UI.

> It's also primarily an issue about what we send over the wire to Web
> sites, a topic that's primarily a Gecko issue and on which the Gecko
> module owners are more likely to be experts.

If there is a technical reason that vendor comments are problematic,
then why is there an API for adding them? I haven't heard any
arguments based on technical expertise that we lack, just a difference
of opinions a philosophical issue based on well-established facts that
we all understand.

_______________________________________________
dev-tech-layout mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-tech-layout

Reply via email to