Joe Bohn wrote:
Joe Bohn wrote:
Joe Bohn wrote:
Jarek Gawor wrote:
On Tue, Mar 11, 2008 at 1:20 PM, Joe Bohn <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
wrote:
5) Should we make all samples plugins? At the moment the
jsp-examples,
servlet-examples, and ldap-sample-app are plugins. The other 12
samples
are not. I'd be in favor of creating a plugin for each and will
work on
doing this unless I hear objections.
I created plugins for all the samples in trunk only. I tested most of
them on jetty only so I would appreciate people trying them on Tomcat.
The samples that require database you will still need to follow the
directions in the sample wiki to create the database and the tables.
I'm actaully still debating if I should add in the gbean to the ear
descriptors to create the databases automatically or not (any thoughts
on that?). I also published all the samples so you should be able to
install the plugins remotely using
http://geronimo.apache.org/plugins/geronimo-2.2/ repo.
Once the plugins look good to everyone we can merge them into
branches/2.1.
Thanks Jarek ... I think it's great to have the plugin option for
those installing samples. I'll see if I can give them a try with a
tomcat server later today.
Regarding the creation of the database and tables; I think it
probably depends on the sample and what it is trying to convey.
Perhaps I'll have a more informed opinion after I try the sample
plugins out on a Tomcat server. However, if creating the database is
central to the purpose of the sample it is probably best not to mask
or confuse this via the gbean. Adding the gbean will impact not only
those leveraging the plugin but also those that are following the
detailed steps for the sample.
Ok, I finally got around to trying out some of the samples on tomcat.
The ones I tried worked just fine. I'll attempt to try them all just
in case there is an issue with one.
I personally don't see any value in keeping the definition of the
database items manual and I think it would be great if we defined
those via the gbean in the ears. I didn't walk through all of the
samples but it doesn't appear to me that defining the db elements is
of any value to the user of the samples. We can still describe what
the gbean is doing for those that are curious.
Just noticed one more thing ... not sure if it is related to the samples
themselves or the plugins of the samples specifically ... but the links
for javadoc and source code don't work.
That's not the plugin. There must be an issue with the archetype, I found this
very same issue while testing the samples directly from branches.
I was documenting these findings here
http://cwiki.apache.org/GMOxDOC21/apache-geronimo-v21-users-guide-development-status.html
Cheers!
Hernan
Joe
