Im not sure I understand your question. I believe the dev list here is rather open to the types of discussion we were having about struts-ajax. It is not my intention to halt that discussion, my point is that I believe Franks initial question was answered, and it is time to begin a discussion, whether that is here, or between those interested in a personal email with cc's, on how to move forward with it.
Perhaps I was a bit blunt in my QA style reply, but I believe the concensus is that: 1) We really don't know how the community as a whole (the users of struts that is) would respond to a struts-ajax integration. Perhaps the user list is a place for that question to be asked so that we can get a feel on if it is worth the effort of starting a project somewhere. 2) The project will not - at least at this point - be included in any official apache offerings, or hosted on their svn repository. Which led me to say we should look into some other venue for hosting such a project. Sourceforge is a perfect place for that. Heck I would be willing to open my cvs at my server to host it, but it is sort of up and down as lately I have been losing DSL about 2 times a week. Not to mention of course if it took off my DSL provider would probably scream at me for operating a "business" :) I'm all for the discussion, but simply saying "come on people Frank is on to something" does none of us any good. Especially when it is just comments that aren't even necessarily about the original proposal. (As with any discussion the subject tends to remain the same and the content shifts) Al -----Original Message----- From: Dakota Jack [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, April 07, 2005 12:39 PM To: Struts Developers List Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: RFC: Struts HTML Ajax-Aware Tags What about the discussion of how to provide a managed environment that encourages rather than punishes participation, Allan. Any interest in that question, or are we doing a medical test of people knee reactions? ///-) --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
