On Monday, November 16, 2015 11:01:50 PM Dan Roberts wrote: > https://docs.google.com/document/d/1EohzxhrgM1Ky4CaKpk72WiUNepFeT5krdReEKxDy > L8o/edit?usp=sharing
Huge thanks for dealing with this! Here's my feedback (you can ignore my IRC private messages if you read the following): - I can't figure out how to specify my name without creating a Google account. My contributions only appear as anonymous. Further, does this thing support a version history? Otherwise, vandalism is difficult to detect. Maybe use the Etherpad/Piratepad stuff instead for easier contribution? Did you notice that Steve had started one already anyway? http://piratepad.net/aZQoDXr5Ym The above is also why I'm only sending you most of my feedback as mail for now instead of fixing it myself right away :) I've commented some stuff there though, and fixed some minor things which don't need discussion. - It should mention what we plan to implement using WoT in a more concise manner, and more close to the start of the document. I'd put that as an enumeration, i.e. something like: * Anonymous forum systems. Already implemented, only needs polishing to be deployed. * Anonymous filesharing. This is our #1 uservoice feature request. Will be implemented using the forum systems. * Anonymous social networking / microblogging (= Twitter). Already implemented, only needs polishing to be deployed. * Anonymous blogging. Already implemented and deployed, only needs polishing to be enabled by default. * Anonymous online shops. Can be implemented using the forum systems, or by supporting OpenBazaar. * Anonymous email. Already implemented and deployed, only needs polishing to be enabled by default. You could figure out more for that list from https://wiki.freenetproject.org/Projects but I think what I listed is already the most important ones - Freetalk, Sone, FlogHelper, Freemail. Those are enough anyway, it's doubtful whether they can finished with a year of funding. These should be mentioned at the beginning due to the reasons my previous mail in this thread described: Our lack of new features over the years sucks. So we should prominently tell users which features they will get. You might also want to mention another aspect I described in the previous mail: Most of those features are already *implemented*, they only need polishing + deployment, which is shame. - Keep the document a bit shorter. Should fit 1 page IMHO. For example, remove the Github/DVCS stuff, would only be interesting for developers, not users. I also implicitly already recommended to shorten the OpenBazaar stuff by only having it in the aforementioned enumeration. - Here's the year count you want to fill in: I've been with Freenet for 7 years. 2 as an employee, 5 as a volunteer. ("/msg NickServ info xor-freenet" to validate :) - I'd use "Web of Trust" instead of "WebOfTrust". Other than that, it's a really nice writeup already, and I'm confident we can use it after some tweaks! :) Thanks again
signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.
_______________________________________________ Devl mailing list Devl@freenetproject.org https://emu.freenetproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/devl
