At 10:50 PM 5/17/2002 -0400, Derek J. Balling wrote:
>If someone falisfies their data, putting in, say "000-000-0000" for a 
>phone number, or 1600 Pennsylvania Ave (for non-.USians, that's the White 
>House), that's an affirmative action they've done which has caused harm to 
>the integrity of the public WHOIS database.

But it's an issue of standing.  You have no business dealing that causes 
you to challenge the information -- your advocacy for "the integrity of the 
public WHOIS database" is touching, but when the database stands up and 
tells us "I was in such pain until Derek saved me" I'll consider that 
useful.  There's nothing that yet gives you a right to have any particular 
piece of information be accurate until you actually ned to use it; 
otherwise, it's make-work.

As for the comparison with the abuse complaint front, that would be like 
your notifying someone's ISP that you'd heard them laughing about the fact 
that they'd signed up for their account using Rush Limbaugh's address and 
phone number. Again, no standing, no abuse, no reason for the call to be 
heeded.

Reply via email to