On 9/9/14 4:39 AM, "Stephen J. Turnbull" <step...@xemacs.org> wrote:
>Kelley, John writes: > > > 1. Auto Forwards, principally where the email is munged in some way > > causing DKIM to fail. > > 2. Mailing lists; although the big ones seem to be rewriting the From > > (thanks). > >From what I've seen on Mailman Project lists[1], your users may not feel >the same way, though. There have been complaints to list owners that >they're getting singled out (a popular Mailman feature, for example, >checks DMARC policy and munges From or wraps the message only if it's >p=reject). > >Have you had any such feedback? I have no such feedback, but it might not come to me. > > > 3. Groups (these might be considered a subset of mailing lists, but > > folks seem to think of them differently) > >What's a "group"? Specifically, how do messages get submitted to >groups and then injected into the mail system? If there are multiple >ways of submitting messages, does it matter which one is used? We had a pow-wow a few days ago and this came up. I believe that for DMARC purposes, we can refer to it as a mailing-list, but it seems as if people think of them differently. I believe that folks use the term group to identify things they "belong" to (neighborhood association, swimming pool) and the term list to identify things they subscribe to. I broke it apart simply because that is the way it was brought up to me. The inner workings are, I am sure, very similar to a mailing list. Perhaps a moderated mailing list. John Kelley > > >Footnotes: >[1] Can't speak from personal experience, all my "p=reject" >subscribers said "thanks for the heads-up" and changed posting >address. > _______________________________________________ dmarc mailing list dmarc@ietf.org https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dmarc
