On 22/04/2026 19:55, [email protected] wrote:
Internet-Draft draft-ietf-dmarc-arc-to-historic-00.txt is now available. It is
a work item of the Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting &
Conformance (DMARC) WG of the IETF.

    Title:   Reclassifying ARC as Historic
    Authors: J. Trent Adams
             John Levine
    Name:    draft-ietf-dmarc-arc-to-historic-00.txt
    Pages:   9
    Dates:   2026-04-22


There appears to be room for improvement in the analysis.

Section 3.1 states that "ARC required evaluators to run a reputation system for ARC 
signers."  This is not accurate.  The only occurrence of the term "reputation" in 
the ARC specification is in Section 7.1.2, where it notes that a site /may/ apply reputation-based 
filtering.  There is no requirement for evaluators to operate such a system.

Section 3.2 is titled "ARC’s Core Lesson: Signatures Are Not Trust".  However, 
DMARC itself relies on trusting authenticated identifiers, whether established via 
cryptographic signatures or IP-based mechanisms.  For direct messages, this model is 
generally effective. There is a qualitative difference, however, when identity is 
asserted transitively (e.g., in forwarding scenarios): authentication alone does not 
convey the same level of trust. Informally, when an entity proves its own identity, this 
can be seen as a kind of “fixed point” of the trust function; this property does not hold 
when identity is asserted on behalf of a third party.

More generally, the use of signatures should be considered within a broader 
authentication and authorization framework.  Internet email has historically 
operated without mandatory authentication, and with an implicit authorization 
model in which any sender can attempt delivery to any recipient without prior 
arrangement.  This openness is a core property of the system.  Forwarding, by 
contrast, introduces third-party assertions of identity, where this implicit 
authorization model no longer applies cleanly.

The draft does not address this distinction, which is significant.  There may 
be a partial parallel with earlier attempts to address mediated message flows, 
such as Sender ID in relation to SPF.  In both cases, mechanisms were 
introduced to extend authentication semantics beyond direct delivery, and the 
resulting difficulties appear to arise less from the underlying cryptography 
than from the complexity of the trust model.  However, the comparison is not 
exact, as ARC operates as an extension to DKIM rather than a reinterpretation 
of identity.


Best
Ale
--





_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to