On Fri 15/May/2026 17:22:59 +0200 Douglas Foster wrote:
The mailing list problem has always been an evaluator problem.   An evaluator who wants to meet the needs of his user needs to figure out which lists can be trusted and then allow all traffic from the list.


Coarse-grained authorizations may become unmanageable, especially when very large mailbox providers are involved.

Allowing a mail stream for all users also seems gameable in the case of free-mail providers.


An alternate approach is to declare the list to be too risky, and block all traffic from the list.   Users can participate from personal Gmail accounts on personal devices, as a fallback.


So users cannot subscribe to low-reputation lists?

Also, what does "participate from personal devices" mean in this context?


The only strategy that makes no sense is allowing some traffic because authentication failure is ignored, while blocking some traffic because authentication is not ignored.


Valid authentication remains valid.  Authorization is a different matter.

I can subscribe myself to any list I like, but I cannot subscribe /you/ to any list. Why should the same authorization decision cover both cases?


Best
Ale
--





_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to