On Sun, 2020-01-19 at 21:42 -0800, Rafael Skodlar wrote:
> On 2020-01-19 16:50, R C wrote:
> > well,  I just want to test a setup, it by no means is going to be a 
> > permanent setup
> > 
> > So X-forwarding would work, and is easy
> > 
> > 
> > Ron
> 
> Running X-windows on CNC machines makes as much sense as mounting saddle 
> on a caw.
> 
> Based on my research LinuxCNC is undesirable in production environments 
> or as an option in new CNC products. I spent countless hours to find out 
> if any CNC manufacturer is recommending or including LinuxCNC with their 
> products. Most small to medium size CNC machines in built or kit forms, 
> come with Mach or some other thing. When the subject matter comes up I 
> don't recommend their product because it's only available on crippled OS.
> 
> After decades of proven good records, there is a lot of misunderstanding 
> about using Linux in small business environments. I hate to write it, 
> but LinuxCNC is not ready for software option with new or DIY CNC 
> machines. When I tried to get small business owners or others at trade 
> shows interested in LCNC I get questions that are impossible to answer. 
> What kind of computer and other electronics HW are needed, who's 
> supporting it, how much does it cost, etc.
> 
> I can't tell people to come ask questions on this mailing list. 
> Discussions more often than not degenerate from the lists main purpose.
> 
> Suggestions to find a used PC or a motherboard with parallel port are 
> just silly. That's fine for hackers with more spare time than $$$ in 
> their pockets but not for serious business owners. During my visit to EU 
> I could not find a used PC to demonstrate LinuxCNC around.
> 
> LinuxCNC is like Apache and such in the 1990s. No serious commercial use 
> and support. I haven't seen any job listing LCNC as one of the 
> requirements advertised anywhere.
> 
> If things were different, open source community would embrace LCNC 
> instead of putting their effort into GRBL for example. My choice would 
> be a headless Linux based CNC controller with suitable drivers for 
> different size machines. GUI would be running on separate system 
> connected over ethernet, USB, or even wireless in some cases. Numerous 
> robots work that way.
> 
> 



That is your desired setup.

I have a pc with parallel port but on it I use a Mesa card, so the
parallel port is useless. I can't find anything better than LinuxCNC to
run my cnc.





_______________________________________________
Emc-users mailing list
Emc-users@lists.sourceforge.net
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/emc-users

Reply via email to