At 11:14 PM -0400 10/6/06, John T Sylvanis wrote:
That may be, the point still remains: produce notation software that has
realistic rendition which then can be recorded to
media. CD or tape or whatever may come in the future, for a demo. This
will liberate the composer from his eternal dependence of the musicians
or conductors. Why should the incredible efforts of so many remain
forever anonymous because they either don't have the money to hire
musicians or connection to a willing conductor to play their work with an
orchestra? When I was a member of the conducting team at a world famous
orchestra, I could only see the piles of hand and painstakingly written
scores that were laying in a corner at the orchestra's library because
the orchestra simply did not have the physical time to fit them into the
season's programs.

I do not answer to challenge you, because your points are very well stated, but to ask what are really a few philosophical questions.

Why are you writing for orchestra, given (a) the difficulty of securing performances, and (b) the expense of producing demos good enough to sell your work. Because in the past the orchestra has been considered the highest form of music making (although there are plenty of opera, choral, and chamber music enthusiasts who would take issue with that)? Beethoven hired and paid his orchestra to play is music, as did Mozart for the last 10 years of his life. And the operative words are "in the past." Many orchestra's programming puts them in the "museum" category to some extent, making it chancy to present new music to your traditional audience. There are segments of the market that DO need and want new music, the most obvious at this point in history being the band and wind ensemble world, but not downplaying choral organizations and educational and religious organizations.

Why are you writing for voices, when it is basically impossible to have a decent vocal sample or set of samples that can produce words?

Why, if you want not to be dependent on live musicians, are you still writing for them instead of going to one or more of the tape techniques (or their present-day descendants) which were developed precisely to do away with the vicissitudes of working with live musicians?

Why do you assume that those who remain anonymous don't deserve to remain so, when over the past very few years a good number of the composers on OrchestraList HAVE obtained not just premiers but repeat performances? Salesmanship is part of promoting your work, and my guess is that conductors have as little time to listen to demos as they do to study new scores. The OrchestraList composers I refer to do not start making their reputations with "world famous orchestras," but more often with fine regional and decent community orchestras. And there are an awful lot more of those than there are "world famous orchestras"!

And, just out of curiosity, what ever happened to the Kurzweil keyboards and their sampled libraries that were so highly touted about 10 years ago as the "perfect samples" for orchestral music, and that had some darned good demos of what could be done with their samples?

John


--
John & Susie Howell
Virginia Tech Department of Music
Blacksburg, Virginia, U.S.A 24061-0240
Vox (540) 231-8411  Fax (540) 231-5034
(mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED])
http://www.music.vt.edu/faculty/howell/howell.html
_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to