Hi, > It is necessary for me to explain the community roles in Seata. The Seata > community includes roles of maintainer, committer, and contributor. In the > actual operation of the community, the committer role in the Seata > community is similar to the PMC (Project Management Committee) member role > in Apache Foundation projects. Contributors can be recommended and > nominated by committers, and after discussion and voting, they can become > new committers only when the number of votes reaches 60% of all committers > and all approval.
The project can choose to have PMC and committers as a group or separate the PMC and committers groups. If the first is intended, it should go into the proposal. It looks like your project will need to change its process, as it is up to the PMC to discuss and vote on new committers and PMC members. Contributors are not selected, and anyone can contribute to an ASF project. Voting in new committers is by the PMC and generally via 3 +1 votes. I think you should use what other projects have done rather than create your own voting rules that require a large majority of people to vote. > From my perspective, some of the current processes in the Seata community > are similar to those of the Apache Foundation and make decisions based on > consensus. Donating Seata to the Apache Foundation not only involves the > transfer of organization, but also includes a shift in roles. Similar to > the PMC mailing list in ASF projects, Seata also has a committer mailing > list, fescar-commit...@googlegroups.com, for private discussions. Some adjustment needs to be made here. All committer conversations must be in public. The project private list is for the PMCs only; only security and voting in new PMC members and committers are discussed on this list; everything is on the development list. > From the perspective of the role model in the Seata community, I think it is > appropriate to use the fescar-committer mailing list for discussions. No sorry IMO it is not, all communication needs to move to ASF infrastructure and existing lists closed. Kind Regards, Justin --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: general-unsubscr...@incubator.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: general-h...@incubator.apache.org
