This is a faulty argument: copyright law entitles you to own the artistic expressions you create, and not the work that went into it. If I would spend a long time to create a piece that happens to be the same as something that Bach wrote, I can not enforce copyright on "my" work. I am not sure about what copyright says about urtexts and other such recent editions of music that is itself in the public domain. Does anyone know a forum where we can get more information about this? I think the place to get better information is from a lawyer rather than from a forum.