------------------------------------------------------------------------
August 25, 2009 - Goanet's 15th Anniversary
------------------------------------------------------------------------
From: "Mario Goveia" <mgov...@sbcglobal.net>
<<<Whether after consultation or not, it is dishonest to pretend to address
"human development" while harming working people by preaching against
outsourcing.
***The Holy Father is not against outsourcing, but against abuses of
outsourcing...
Anyone who finds outsourcing beneficial in their business but is not doing
so because of the Pope is harming his or her business, by definition.
***You have not yet understood what the Holy Father is teaching.
Fr. Ivo wrote:
> The Holy Father is right, whereas Mario is wrong. Benedict XVI did not
"end" outsourcing ("if outsourcing were to end"), but "guided" it. Read
the text before you criticise.
If anyone followed his "guidance" at their cost, he did not do them any
favors, and harmed those who would have received the outsourced jobs as
well..
***Then you are free to continue to do what you are doing...
>>>The shareholders own the company and no other "stakeholders" would
benefit if it were not for them. So what if they have geographical
mobility? The fact is that they have invested in a particular business
which has to maximize its resources so that all the "stakeholders" can
benefit in the long run.
***This is precisely what Benedict XVI is saying...
In short, as I said earlier, "Benedict XVI is not against outsourcing, but
is appealing to responsibility towards all the stakeholders over mere
profitability of shareholders"...
Mario responds:
There would be no successful "stakeholders" without successful
"shareholders" making "mere" profits.
***If all profit, then it is correct according to Benedict XVI.
<<< Memo to Goanetters: Please note that Fr. Ivo and Pope's JP II and Benny
have never had to make anything so crass as "mere" profits.
***If the Church (priests, convents or monasteries) makes profit, you will
say that they are concerned with money affairs...
As a businessman myself, the Vatican can PLEASE keep it's "guidance" to
itself and use it in any businesses it owns. Listening to their
non-expert advice would hamper my business.
***You can follow your ways, please... Donations will come from evwerywhere.
You can offer him shoes bought in Dharavi and insure seats in heaven...
Regards.
Fr.Ivo
