Tuning the horn to a different key does not bring in a lot of new technical problems. Sorry. But I do find it odd that you first claim I never play these pieces as a solo, then when I do, they just aren't professional enough. Move goalposts much? Your method was still to use another horn besides playing in E, correct? Of course you're going to use the 3rd finger less if you read in F. You also say that woodwinds don't have to worry about the third finger because they're skilled enough to use it, then when I bring up the fact that they avoid it as much as they can it's some other excuse. Oh, and the third finger problems arise with transitions between third finger combinations and the third finger due to the tendons I'm talking about. I'm not trying to be disrespectful, but it seems that no matter what I say you will gainsay it in favor of tradition or something. Well tradition is often the last bad performance. Rational thought should be based on reason, not what you have always done. If there are solid reasons for doing something in another fashion, then by all means do it. I have my reasons (which are well founded) for tuning the way I do, and reasons (which are also well founded) for playing E pieces in Eb with an F#/B horn. People are different. You may use your way, I will use mine. And as for 'working hard enough' - you're never going to make a silk purse out of a sow's ear - and you're never going to fix the problems with the third finger without some sort of Star Trek type invention, sorry. There are physical limitations - and no matter how much you say "just work hard" or "yes you can" will not change some aspects of reality. I don't care how much wishing I do - I'm not going to change the boiling point of water at 1 atmosphere nor am I going to magically remove the tendons that are in my hand to facilitate better movement. -William In a message dated 11/27/2009 1:55:50 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, [email protected] writes:
Honestly asking, do we have to play rapid passages as do the woodwinds or a piano player ? No, by no means !!! And how about the fiddle players with their multi phonics involving more than two fingers the same time ???? It is absolutely weird, using a defect of a prominent player as an excuse for one´s own inability. I thought, in your country everything would be possible "if you work hard enough". "Yes we can !" ....... And my method does not need alternated fingerings nor much involvement of the third finger. There are just less than 100 ab1 to play in the whole op.45 and no other use of the 3rd finger. Is that difficult ? A lot of these ab1 are held & well prepared, at some other spots you have other choice than using 23. But, I admit, doing it on the Bb-side, well, it is finger breaking but still can be mastered, if one has studied thoroughly the fingerings on both sides of the horn. If you talk about natural weakness of the third finger, well, you have forgotten that we do it with handicap anyway as we finger the things on left hand. What should extreme climbers say about weakness in certain fingers or toes. Mental automated control is requested there & for us horn players as well. As you see, just tuning the horn differently by adding a different slide & pull the valve slides out will bring a lot of technical problems. Why to do so & recommend it to others, as there are much simpler solutions: playing discipline, abandoning old habits. And "leaving the church in the village", it is a big difference (not in excitement) playing such pieces professionally (I mean for money !) or for fun, because wanting to play them with all the consequences. Professionals have to bear the consequences if they fail as a soloist. But you have another job. ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ +++++ Am 27.11.2009 um 17:46 schrieb [email protected]: > I have performed a Rosetti concerto AND the von Weber in public before (and > with orchestra) and I did it exactly as I described. But of course I also > mentioned a good tuning system that works with a horn in any key but that > was poopooed thoroughly on this list. (Even though it works.) I had no > problems with it and I've actually won and placed in a few regional music > competitions using this method on pieces in E. > > To me, it's not difficult with proper ear training because it is no problem > for me to sing/whistle/play something in a different key. It's just a > different key, that's all. > > As for the third finger - it's anatomy. There are two tendons joining it to > your middle finger and pinky. There is an anatomical weakness there which > you are never going to get rid of. Don't you know your history about Robert > Schumann and his third finger? > > I don't care who you are personally, but if you are human you are going to > be born with this deficiency. > > There is no way (unless you have a mutated hand) that you will EVER be able > to play keys with a lot of third finger combinations as well as you are > going to play something in a key with a lot of 1's 2's or 12's together. > > And I do look at clarinets and flutists - and you should know as well > enough as I that they have many many alternate fingerings FOR THIS EXACT REASON. > > -William > > > In a message dated 11/27/2009 2:38:35 A.M. Eastern Standard Time, > [email protected] writes: > > Honestly, William, when did you play one of these concertos in E in public > for the last time ? Did you ? As a horn player with eventual problems on > the F-side in certain regions of the horns compass, honestly ??? And tuning > the horn differently than standard e.g. in A/E instead of Bb/F or E/A > instead of F/Bb ? Isn´t that difficult enough for players with explicit good ear > training ? Honestly ?? How about hitting the right notes right on, if the > horn plays different than you finger the note ?? Honestly. > > If you are that good, why should it be a problem for you. Why should the > use of the third finger be avoided ? Look at the clarinetists or flutists > how many keys they have to activate at the same time. Honestly !! Is it so > difficult just thinking to use the F-side up to the written g2 (top of the > staff) ? Is it so difficult to change decade old habits ? > > As we can learn foreign or even dead languages, it should not be more > difficult, re-learning the complete fingering of our instrument(s). > > I know what´s your and many other´s problem: you are not exposed enough to > play for other people than for yourself. You are not exposed e.g. to > transposing in all different keys day by day. If you were, these problems would > not exist. Right ? You might admit it. It would not be a shame. You would > speak for the mass of players who play for fun. > > But I might ask you here, why do you talk about the extremes (Rosetti & > C.M.v.Weber) here, pieces avoided by most professional players because of > reasons said before (near exclusive use of the Bb-side, thus difficulties with > parts in E, speaking of solo parts) ? > > I remember a now deceased longtime colleague and good friend, who borrowed > first horn parts of rarely performed Richard Strauss operas from our > library, took them to his summer vacation home & tried to impress the farmer > band horn players by "what he had to play in his job". > > Take it easy. I am sure there is no Weber op.45 or Rosetti no.3 double > concerto coming up for you the next time. Let us be real. I never played that > Rosetti even I have both sets of parts in E & in Eb (they are part of my > publications !), but I played the Weber op.45 about 20-times with different > orchestras. There is a DVD with a professional TV recording. > > Finally: you are right, the A=440 in the USA is a problem for horns from > Europe. If one has to pull the slides more out when the horn is converted to > E/A it is a problem. If Engelbert Schmidt had prepared slids with double > extensions ....... but then you would have a general problem how to pull at > all ..... > > ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ > +++ > > Am 27.11.2009 um 02:49 schrieb [email protected]: > >> My main problem with that is in the states the tuning is usually all > A=440 >> so you end up with slides that are about at their limit on my horn in E > - >> and I'd much rather not have to deal with a slide on the verge of > popping >> out at the slightest jolt. If the tuning is slightly higher then it > probably >> gives the slide a bit more room to grip the tubing. >> >> But that is how the Horn was for me. >> >> Making the horn sharp to read in Eb works for me - especially for > Rosetti >> or von Weber where shorter horns help my endurance as well as Eb > fingerings >> being slightly smoother for me than F. Plus I love to read in Eb. >> >> Different strokes for different folks. >> >> On a side note, I've also ran into 'purists' who insist on just learning > >> the part in E - but the trouble with that is the fingerings will never > be >> smooth and it's making it much more difficult on yourself. The audience >> doesn't know what key it's in or care how much of a finger buster it is > - so why n >> ot use every advantage you can get. Plus it wasn't originally written > for >> an F horn either. Besides if you can sound great on the von Weber, > imagine >> how much better you can sound with smoother finger transitions. >> >> I kind of side with pianists - if you can ever avoid using the third > finger >> or a third finger combination - avoid it. There are plenty of great > pieces >> in E - and if you can afford a nice horn that transposes these for you > for >> solo work go ahead. Whatever you can do to eliminate any disadvantages > for >> a performance is my train of thought. Besides, it's music, not a > circus. >> >> -William >> >> >> >> >> In a message dated 11/26/2009 8:35:33 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, >> [email protected] writes: >> >> Schmidts philosophy is a bit different than yours, perhaps. It is about >> the same as they do/did in Vienna e.g. for the Fidelio (Leonore´s great > Aria >> in E, played on the horn converted to A-horn, makes Eb fingering for > the >> part in E). So be it for the op.45 by Weber also. >> I did it much easier, playing all most on the F-side, except some > higher >> entrances. Works, if you do not stick to the rule "up from g on 2nd > line >> from below on the Bb-side always". >> >> Happy Thanksgiving to all. >> >> >> _______________________________________________ >> post: [email protected] >> unsubscribe or set options at > https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/hpizka%40me.com > > _______________________________________________ > post: [email protected] > unsubscribe or set options at > https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/valkhorn%40aol.com > > _______________________________________________ > post: [email protected] > unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/hpizka%40me.com _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/valkhorn%40aol.com _______________________________________________ post: [email protected] unsubscribe or set options at https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org
