Something else to consider - a desire to play an E piece on a true E horn
or a cleaner transposition is in no way indicative that the person cannot
play it on an F horn in E.
Let's face the truth - there are many avenues to get from point A to point
B - and some work for some and some work for others. We've established that
some people want to play a piece in E on an E horn, an F#/B horn (even
Schmid himself has suggested this before so I'm not the first). If you can
perform the piece well and musically and _not miss_, WHO CARES.
I frankly prefer playing an E piece on an F#/B horn. So what. I've
performed it that way, competed on E pieces that way, and have won/placed in
competitions that way.
All I did (just like my tuning method) was offer yet another avenue.
How many times have new ideas or new methods been squashed in the realm of
music because it wasn't tradition? If we were truly sticklers for tradition
why would we ever touch Mahler.
-William
_______________________________________________
post: [email protected]
unsubscribe or set options at
https://pegasus.memphis.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/options/horn/archive%40jab.org