Erik,

> Folks have talked about two ways of addressing this (so that ARP, 
> Neighbor Discovery and applications use of IP multicast can be supported)
>  - a multicast emulation sublayer

The *Ethernet compatibility layer* of 802.16 (actually called the Convergence 
Sublayer) specifies only how Ethernet frames are to be encapsulated over 802.16 
wireless connections. This implies that Ethernet CS does not emulate Ethernet 
like functionality and multicast/broadcast frames can not be processed at the 
802.16 MAC layer. These frames are sent to Ethernet Layer, which in turn may 
send to 802.16 MAC, to send out these multicast/broadcast frames there should 
be a downlink multicast/broadcast connection to which all MSs listening to. And 
the basic thing is, even if Ethernet has broadcast support, the layer below 
does not have efficient mechanism to handle broadcast/multicast packets. To 
provide a functional emulation of Ethernet, several additional definitions and 
functional elements are necessary (dealt with 16ng solution)

>  - in addition, figure out ways that Neighbor Discovery can rely on less
>    multicast

>From the IP CS perspective, the mention above is an applicable concern.

I think the text below was trying to indicate that: 

"....because of the existence of multiple Convergence Sublayers which 
makes the specification of IP over IEEE 802.16 non-trivial."

Let me describe your comments in each deliverable more detail...

Daniel (Soohong Daniel Park)
Mobile Convergence Laboratory, SAMSUNG Electronics.

--------------------------------------------------------------------
IETF IPv6 working group mailing list
ipv6@ietf.org
Administrative Requests: https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ipv6
--------------------------------------------------------------------

Reply via email to