Hi Mukul, Thanks for the update.
I was relieved to get away from the previous level of uncertainty that I was doing something stupid! I'm not sure what was happening before to give us those discrepancies between our respective results though. Did you try comparing the files you were using for the validations before with the new (but, from my point of view, the same) files from the Jira case? > When I remove the XML comment from line 40 of the file test2.xml, I get 9 XSD > validation errors > for the file test2.xml after removal of XML comment. This looks to me > strange, and may be a bug > with Xerces-J and should be investigated I believe. Yes, this would be because the subsequent XML comments are no longer aligned with the problematic line numbers. What can I expect to happen next? Is there some process where one of the Xerces-J Developers (assuming that you are not already one of those) will pick up this case? If so, how long does that process typically take, in your experience? I wonder whether it would help my case, if you could add your supporting information, that you had succeeded in replicating the problem, to the Jira case itself? All the best, John. > On 28 August 2020 at 04:47 Mukul Gandhi <muk...@apache.org> wrote: > > > Hi John, > > > On Wed, Aug 26, 2020 at 7:47 PM JOHN Morris < j.morri...@ntlworld.com> wrote: > > > Also, I wonder whether I could get you to send me the exact outputs from > > your jaxp.SourceValidator runs on the two files test1.xml (9 errors) and > > test2.xml (18 errors). > > I just saw that, you've created a Jira issue XERCESJ-1726 for this > discussion. Thanks. > > I'm now able to reproduce the issues described by you within this discussion. > > I've now used, the XML documents (test1.xml & test2.xml) and an XSD document > (test.xsd) that you've attached to the above mentioned Jira issue. With those > files, the XML document test1.xml gives me 9 XSD validation errors, and the > file test2.xml gives me no XSD validation errors. > > When I remove the XML comment from line 40 of the file test2.xml, I get 9 XSD > validation errors for the file test2.xml after removal of XML comment. This > looks to me strange, and may be a bug with Xerces-J and should be > investigated I believe. > > > Is there a command-line option for jaxp.SourceValidator which would produce > > additional lines in the output for the original XML from each line in the > > input file, whether valid or not? > > I guess that, there's no such command line option with jaxp.SourceValidator. > Inherently, after validation using jaxp.SourceValidator, either we see line > and column numbers with error descriptions for the instances that are > involved in invalidity assessment for the XML and XSD documents, or if the > XML document is valid the output displays nothing (except the time it took > for the XSD validation to take place). > > > -- > > > Regards, > Mukul Gandhi --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: j-users-unsubscr...@xerces.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: j-users-h...@xerces.apache.org
