In a message dated 1/7/02 5:49:45 AM, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:

>I think that this film does not begin to catch the true pain and horror
>of paranoid schizophrenia. Nash comes off as an arrogant, albeit lovable 
quirky
>kinda guy with a penchant for newsprint wallpaper and string art.  It doesn't
>begin to capture the mean and vicious persona that emerges when paranoid
>schizophrenia is in full bloom. 

This depresses me.  Schizophrenia is a terrible illness. I hate it when such 
things are sanitized.  It just confirms the cynical adage that normal people 
can't handle very much reality.  The reality of schizophrenia is people in 
jail (mentally ill people are put in jail quite often), on the street, 
perhaps in the hospital, or living in some sort of sheltered situation, quite 
possibly on disability.  Few people, at least in the throes of a significant 
episode, can cope much better than this.  Just see E. Fuller Torrey's 
Surviving Schizophrenia or Carol North's autobiography, Welcome Silence.  One 
of the highest-functioning persons with schizophrenia I know of is Frederick 
Frese, and he's had problems too.  He's got an article on coping with 
schizophrenia: http://www.mentalhealth.com/story/p52-sc04.html

he says that 

"For those of us who have returned and have found that we are not as welcome 
as we would like to be, we have a challenge. We must work together to change 
the image we have with those in what I sometimes refer to as the "the 
chronically normal community." As more and more of us are becoming open about 
the nature of our disability, we have an obligation to share with others as 
much as we can about mental illness so that there is less fear and greater 
understanding and acceptance."

I really don't see how sanitized movies help achieve that goal.

Mary K

People hurry by so quickly
Don't they hear the melodies
In the chiming and the clicking
And the laughing harmonies
- Joni Mitchell

Reply via email to