begin  quoting Andrew Lentvorski as of Sun, Oct 21, 2007 at 03:36:49PM -0700:
[snip]
> It's big-time vapor.
> 
> This is a combination of a hard technical problem with a "really good 
> idea that nobody will pay for".
 
I think you underestimate the gamer community.

Or the lure of the shiny.

> The major problem is that you need to run wires into *each key*.  This 
> is completely contrary to the way keyboards are made in which all the 
> wiring is on the backplane and the keys are just stupid hunks of plastic 
> that push on a rubber sheet with nipples (they really do look like 
> that).  When a key squishes a nipple, it makes electrical contact with 
> the backplane.
> 
> OLED needs continuous power.  That's going to be a non-starter.  Imagine 
> threading ribbon cables to every single key.  Shudder.

hmmm..... that would be neat. It would (or might) be easier to remap the
control key... -- just swap cables!

> Something like E-Ink that doesn't need continuous power would be a 
> better choice.  You might be able to injection mold the key around the 
> electronics and only need to intermittently power the key when you need 
> to change it.  This could possibly even be done contactless.
 
I would expect this sort of thing to take place first, yes.

> In addition, nobody will pay for the keyboard.  There are *very* few 
> people who actually need a keyboard which reconfigures on the fly. 
> This, in fact, goes against the usage of a keyboard which is completely 
> based upon muscle memory.  So, you need the keyboard until muscle memory 
> kicks in, and then it's useless.

Imagine the iTunes Visualizer ... on the keyboard.

Imagine color-coordinating your keyboard with your desktop background.

The concept is sufficiently shiny that, if the technical difficulties
were overcome, uses *would* be made of it.  Not needful, necessarily,
but 90% of what's driving the market these days isn't *needful*.

It's glitz.

It's the shiny.

-- 
Why yes, I watched _Firefly_ recently. Why do you ask?
Stewart Stremler


-- 
[email protected]
http://www.kernel-panic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/kplug-list

Reply via email to