> I think it's missing a lot of important information like the stuff > from OperaTrackStyle. Because classical stuff is released on CDs and > not as "works" I think work info is necessary in track titles (as does > the CSG). If we just had a "Symphony No. 5 in C minor" work-release, > then we wouldn't really need to put "Symphony No. 5 in C minor" in > each track title–but we don't so we have to ;) > > I think these titles should be at least: > > Matthew Passion, BWV 244: Choral "Herzliebster Jesu, was hast du > verbrochen" > Matthew Passion, BWV 244: "Da das Jesus merkete" (Evangelista, Jesus) > etc.
I'd agree with Aaron here - bare minimum, the first of the two above. A side note to this, by the way, I've noticed a few new classical editors just in the past few days who have been going through and either adding new releases or editing existing releases into the "no work in the title" format you're suggesting; when I've asked why, they've said they're using some of the trial-balloon edits like this one as examples from "classical editors who know how to do it". Just wanted to add the note of caution when we do do trial balloon edits like this; some of the editors who don't participate in the lists and who don't really know CSG well yet are paying attention to everything we do, but not the reasons we do it... While I'm writing here anyhow, I would really like to get things moving towards resolution / approval on the work list stuff so we can get back to CSG. The RFC and such have been out for several weeks now - is there anyone who would veto at this point; or if we held the work list RFCs until luks actually has work lists implemented, would there be anyone now opposed to the part of that RFC that moved the "full details" CSG to be only for work lists? (We also still need to discuss, as like with this trial series of edits, what would then be "simple classical style" for use on the releases themselves, if the full CSG is moved away from that purpose...) Brian _______________________________________________ Musicbrainz-style mailing list Musicbrainz-style@lists.musicbrainz.org http://lists.musicbrainz.org/mailman/listinfo/musicbrainz-style
