> > Btw, I also considered only using ARs for this and link the songs to > > Beatles or Britney Spears by ARs, but at the end I found it more > > practical to use a direct artist link. Using only ARs would be > > cleaner, but it would require a different user interface, which would > > delay NGS even more. Migrating from the direct artist link to ARs in > > the future shouldn't be that difficult. > > So, works for pop artists would be filed under the pop artists, not > the composer?
Imho, at least, no - I'd agree that that would be counter to the point of works... (Plus, then, who is the artist when dealing with a work performed by multiple different pop artists? Wouldn't this essentially fragment works into being a useless version of the recordings list?) > That actually does sound quite useful as a way to find > all "songs" by an artist, I'd think that purpose would be handled by the Artist Recordings listing, not the Works listing... > ignoring different versions, but opposite to > what I had assumed and not what I typically think of as a "work". Agreed. Brian
_______________________________________________ Musicbrainz-style mailing list Musicbrainz-style@lists.musicbrainz.org http://lists.musicbrainz.org/mailman/listinfo/musicbrainz-style
