randy, On Sun, Apr 27, 2008 at 12:12:24PM +0900, Randy Bush wrote: > [ moved to futures ] > > how much of the ipv6 content marty submitted was rejected by the pc?
i believe that marty neither submitted nor recruited any ipv6 content (or any other content for that matter). most nanog attendees never submit any presentations because they're busy building and operating networks, which is part of what makes our jobs on the program committee harder. we'd certainly look forward to any relevant, operational content that's directly about ipv6, but the community seems to have decided that the operational issues related to v6 are the ones that we do have presentations on: v4 address exhaustion and trading policy, and docsis 3.0 cable rollout issues. we got very mixed feedback about the v6 content at nanog 41 in albuquerque: many people came just for that, but many other attendees thought it was overkill. we didn't reject a single v6 talk for brooklyn, but that's because we didn't receive any. marty: did you submit or recruit any talk on anything at all that you think was misjudged by the PC? did you suggest to someone on the PC that we recruit a specific talk that we didn't follow up on? if so, please let me know immediately and we'll try to get more on the ball for nanog 44 in LA. if this is more just freeform grousing, that's welcome, too. but constructive feedback about what, specifically, you were hoping for (and who you thought might product that presentation) would be useful. > or > is this yet another case of tell others what they should do? i believe the latter. which really is ok, since we like feedback from the community about what they want/expect/hopefor in the content of the conference. we also really like presentations, though, so if someone thinks there's some good content on what is going on in ipv6-land that is relevant to operators of Internet-connected networks, we'd be happy to review it and give it a platform if we find it relevant. t. -- _____________________________________________________________________ todd underwood +1 603 643 9300 x101 renesys corporation general manager babbledog [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://www.renesys.com/blog _______________________________________________ Nanog-futures mailing list [email protected] http://mailman.nanog.org/mailman/listinfo/nanog-futures
