With the lack of feedback I'm gonna assume the design is fine or just
uninteresting. So therefore I was thinking about commiting this stuff to svn.
My suggestion for location is under rtl/video_out_test.  Any other
suggestion?

That is fine with me. maybe rtl/test_video_out so that all our test modules are alphabetically printed together. One could make the same argument with wanting to have all the video_out code alphabetically printed together, so it doesn't really matter which one we choose, as long as we choose one and stick with it for all our test modules.

Nicholas, let me know if you think there is something missing or that I could
have done better.

Looks fine, but there are two things it is lacking:
1) It might be nice to have a trivial Makefile so that you just can type make analog; make test; gimp analog.ppm or whatever. Perhaps with:
        a. analog, testing analog output.
        b. digital, testing digital output.
        c. both, testing both of them.
        d. debug, which builds the VCD file,
        e. and test, for running the chosen mode.
I'd be happy to write this if you want me to, it should take about a minute. 2) It does not support multiple output frames. This doesn't really matter as much as the Makefile right now, but it is nice to have once we get into more complicated test cases, or if it is integrated into Bochs and the like.

The files are also missing licenses at the top, with author, etc.

Besides that, the code itself runs great! I am glad to see we finally got a version worthy of commit.


nick
_______________________________________________
Open-graphics mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.duskglow.com/mailman/listinfo/open-graphics
List service provided by Duskglow Consulting, LLC (www.duskglow.com)

Reply via email to