On Wed, Jun 17, 2009 at 6:53 PM, Danek Duvall<danek.duvall at sun.com> wrote: > On Wed, Jun 17, 2009 at 05:59:13PM -0600, Jim Walker wrote: > >> Mark Martin wrote: >>> Please find attached (and text inline) the draft opinion for 2008/772 >>> Command Assistant. ? Commentary, concerns, criticisms, and corrections >>> wanted. ?Please. >>> _ >>> >>> ? ? ? ? ? Project Private: >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/CommnadAssistant.jar >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/lib/jaxb-api.jar >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/lib/sjsxp.jar >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/lib/jsr173_api.jar >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/lib/jaxws-api.jar >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/lib/jsr250-api.jar >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/lib/FastInfoset.jar >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/lib/jaxb-xjc.jar >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/lib/streambuffer.jar >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/lib/jaxws-rt.jar >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/lib/http.jar >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/lib/saaj-api.jar >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/lib/jsr181-api.jar >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/lib/jaxws-tools.jar >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/lib/saaj-impl.jar >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/lib/stax-ex.jar >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/lib/jaxb-impl.jar >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? /usr/lib/commandassistant/lib/activation.jar >>> >> >> I cases where jar files are useful beyond Command Assistant >> why don't they get moved to /usr/share/lib/java for other >> applications to use? > > Indeed, given that SAAJ and JAXB are both ARCed (2009/236 and 2009/237, > respectively), why not use those? ?Stax is 2009/055. ?Activation is > 2009/193. ?Not sure about the rest. > > Sorting the files is very helpful for understanding what's going on, too. >
I'm forwarding these concerns on to the team to see if they can address them at this late stage. The delay in the opinion is, of course, my fault, but as Jim C noted in a later reply, the vote's already been cast. I'll sort the files as you indicated, Danek, and repost this on cr.opensolaris.org later today.
