Hi Ron:

That is what I was looking for.... So, we agree that it is not the
modalities but the difference in principle that seperate the professions.
That is what I believe (something like the DO/ MD model but, not totally
like it) . At least, theoretically that's what it boils down to. Obviously,
you realize on further interrogation one may ask- what's the end result
(goal) for increased tolerance, increased balance, decreased pain, decreased
stiffness- all would lead to the same goal- increased occupational
independence, whether or not that is addressed directly on paper.

Again, I do believe that OTs have a role at the impairment level as well
before it becomes a disability (that may be compensated for) or handicap (by
shallow definition, it is one that cannot be compensated for).  I do not
view,  physical dysfunction= impairment and occupational dysfunction=
disability/ handicap. A true physical dysfunction would manifest in an
abnormal/ subnormal occupational performance, hence, is an occupational
deprivation (disallowing people to indulge in occupation) or limitation.
Example: The client has pain, still manages to be independent in dressing
but takes him 3 times longer and a lot more ouches, risking increased tissue
damage with inappropriate compensation. I do believe in this case too, OT is
indicated. While it may seem that per history the person is still
occupationally independent, in my opinion that is a pathological function
hence, a dysfunction- an occupational dysfunction spriting out of physical
dysfunction.  If the pain was no bother, why would he need any services at
all? Insurances don't pay for aesthetic increase in ROM, muscle strength
(call it power/ girth), or subjective decrease in pain by mere numbers.
There has to be a 'functional' outcome- good balance (3 points increase in
Tinneti's) for _________, 4/5 strength to ___________, pain <4/5 to
facilitate ____________, etc....

Here is what AOTA talks about OT services:
http://www.aota.org/featured/area6/
" How Occupational Therapy Works
Every day, children and adults have or develop health conditions that
significantly affect their ability to manage their daily lives. With the
help of occupational therapy, many of these individuals can achieve or
regain a higher level of independence. When skill and strength cannot be
developed or improved, occupational therapy offers creative solutions and
alternatives for carrying out daily activities."

Clearly, OTs try to normalize function, treat at the impairment level as
well and when that's not possible go for alternatives/ adaptations
(ofcourse, with a residual disability/ handicap).









----- Original Message -----
From: "Ron Carson" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: "Joe Wells" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Sent: Saturday, August 30, 2003 4:14 AM
Subject: Re[4]: [OTlist] PT does it all!!


> Hello Joe:
>
> I  believe  that for the most part, it is not the modality that make the
> difference between OT/PT, it is the goal and the theory behind the goal.
> If  a  therapist  is  standing in the kitchen stacking dishes, the could
> very  likely be either an OT or PT. Basically, it boils down to a simple
> question  of  why  is  the therapist doing the treatment and what is the
> goal.
>
> If  the treatment is to improve standing balance then it is more closely
> aligned  to  physical  dysfunction  and  thus  physical  therapy. If the
> treatment  is  to  improve  meal  preparation,  then  it is more closely
> aligned to occupation and thus occupational therapy.
>
> I try to put treatments on a continuum that looks something like this:
>
> physical dysfn <--------------------------------> occupational dysfn
>
>            (NOTE: for non-US readers, 'dysfn' = dysfunction)
>
> The more closely a therapist is working to improve physical dysfunction,
> the  more close they are working in the realm of PT. The same concept is
> true  for  occupational dysfunction. As with all continuums, there is NO
> clear   cut  delineation  between  the  end  points.  However,  for  any
> treatment,  there  comes  a  point  in which one is primarily working to
> improve physical dysfunction or occupational dysfunction.
>
> Having  said  all  of  the  above,  I  clearly  understand  that the two
> endpoints   are   related,  however,  they  ARE  separate.  Many  times,
> therapists  have  said  something  like "well, you can't have occupation
> with  out  physical  function".  I  believe  that that statement is very
> false.  If it were true, then every person with an impairment would have
> disability  and  handicap.  And,  we  know that that isn't the case. For
> example,  just  because  you  can't  raise  your  arm  due  to  a stroke
> (impairment), that doesn't mean that you can't drive a car (disability).
> Or,  just  because  you  can't  move  your  legs due to MS (impairment),
> doesn't mean that you can't prepare a meal (disability).
>
> At  some  point,  an OT working with clients having physical impairments
> must accept that they are primarily concerned more with ameliorating the
> physical   dysfunction   or   more   with  decreasing  the  occupational
> dysfunction. It will probably not surprise anyone to hear me say that by
> definition,  all  OT's  should  be  primarily  concerned with decreasing
> occupational  dysfunction  rather than physical dysfunction. Please bear
> in  mind,  the decreasing occupational dysfunction certainly may include
> working  on  physical impairment, but from an this perspective, physical
> dysfunction  is  not  the  problem  and  thus  it is not the issue to be
> primarily addressed.
>
> As  far  as  OT's  using  physical  agent  modalities in preparation for
> occupation,  it  think  the  concept  is  a  bunch of hooey. Again, as a
> therapist,  you  should  be working on the person's occupation and in my
> mind,  that's how the treatment should be phrased. So, IF a client can't
> brush  their  teeth  because pain/stiffness is keeping them from holding
> their  toothbrush  AND  brushing  their  teeth  is  an client-identified
> occupation  AND  a  treatment  goal,  then  an  OT  using physical agent
> modalities  is  actually  working  to  improve  the  occupation,  not to
> decrease  pain/stiffness.  In  this case, if the treating therapist were
> asked  why  the patient was receiving the physical agent treatment, they
> could  clearly  say, "Mr Jones wants to brush his teeth but his pain and
> stiffness  is  keeping him from doing so. So we are working to allow him
> to brush his teeth".
>
> I  think  all  my rhetoric can be easily boiled down into one statement:
> What  is  the specific goal for the patient. If the goal is to improve a
> specific  occupation  that the client has identified as important, then,
> regardless of the treatment modality, a person is doing OT.
>
> Ron
>
> =============================================
>
> On 8/29/2003,[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
>
> JW> Hi Ron & others:
>
> JW> What are your thoughts on PTs working on standing tolerance with the
> JW> client's  favorite  leisure-  a  game  of  checkers, or, a homemaker
> JW> working  in  PT  stacking  dishes  in  overhead cupboards working on
> JW> standing  balance  post  THR  ....  are  they  working  on  physical
> JW> functions  with  an  'occupational'  modality?  What about OTs using
> JW> contrast-bath treatments in preparation to self care, since it helps
> JW> decrease  stiffness/  pain in the clients hands before holding on to
> JW> their  toothbrush? 'Physical ' modalities for occupational purposes?
> JW> Again,  do  or  don't  art/  music  therapists  use art/ music as an
> JW> 'occupational'  modality (ofcourse, not calling it that), even if it
> JW> is  mainly  diversional  in nature. I have heard of music therapists
> JW> working  with  autistic, ADHD kids that helps 'occupy' the kids in a
> JW> more  constructive  ways  rather  than  their  rather 'mis' or 'dis'
> JW> occupation. I am not convinced that by law or, in actual practice we
> JW> have a true domain that's not been shared by others. Again, I do not
> JW> believe  PTs  have  one either. At least, not in the US. Again, I do
> JW> not  believe  that this con'fusion' leading to the 'fission' amongst
> JW> the  professionals  is  just  limited  to  the  US. I believe the OT
> JW> product is undersold and under-recognized throughout the world, i.e,
> JW> wherever it is.
>
> JW> Our  product  is  like a liquid, it takes the form of the container-
> JW> the flexibility is what makes it an art to conform to the uniqueness
> JW> of  the  individual  that  goes beyond the science of pathology. The
> JW> product  is  holistic- aimed at health in terms of physical, mental,
> JW> emotional  and  social  well-being. I agree it is not a product that
> JW> can  be  defined,  rather  it  has  several  definitions  based upon
> JW> different  settings.  In fact, not too long ago there was an article
> JW> in  Advance  or, OT Practice ( just not sure which) and, it depicted
> JW> analogy of a few blind men describing an elephant with no one having
> JW> ever  seeing  one  before,  and each described it based on what part
> JW> they  came  in  contact  with.  Each  of  them  were right, just not
> JW> complete....
>
> JW> Think of gasoline- it has no form of its own, yet it makes different
> JW> cars  run  from  concept to vintages, luxury to economy....the power
> JW> behind  the  drive! To me that is OT or, that could be. Human bodies
> JW> are the vehicles- life the journey! (...disregard my bad poetry) :-)
>
> JW> p.s:  In the above analogy (bad poetry), the tires of the car is PT,
> JW> as the body of the car is borne on it and, it helps to move/ run it.
> JW> Just kidding!!!!!
>
> JW> Everybody have a great labor day weekend.
>
> JW> Joe
>
> JW> ----- Original Message ----- From: "Ron Carson" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> JW> To:  "Joe  Wells"  <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>  Sent: Friday, August 29, 2003
> JW> 7:31 PM Subject: Re[2]: [OTlist] PT does it all!!
>
> >> Hello Joe:
>
> >> The  OT's profession true and unique domain is that of occupation. In
> >> my little world, it's as simple as that.
>
> >> You  also  mention  that we have an excellent product. I believe that
> >> our  'product'  is  so  laterally  flattened  by  different  practice
> >> patterns and theories that is hard to even define our product.
>
> >> Ron
>
> >> =============================================
>
> >> On 8/28/2003,[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
>
> >> JW> Re: [OTlist] PT does it all!!Amanda:
>
> >> JW>  I  agree. We have an excellent product, just have a lesser brand
> >> JW>  name.  A  few  weeks  ago,  I had posted how a show on Discovery
> >> channel JW> kept showing OTs and called everything PT. Although, both
> >> JW>  professions  developed almost side by side, it is interesting to
> >> see  JW>  the difference in the public perception and acceptance that
> >> comes JW> from it.
>
> >> JW> Ron, it is a reality. Though not all PTs practice what we OTs JW>
> >> thought  or  still  think  is  our domain, but more and more are, JW>
> >> especially since it's been published under their practice acts by JW>
> >> APTA.  The  PT  profession  does aim at being a wholesome 'rehab/ JW>
> >> therapy'  provider. And, it is highly endorsed by APTA. Although, JW>
> >> AOTA  endorses  a similar stance, I just don't see enough enthusiasm/
> >> JW>  confidence  within  the  profession, let alone public education.
> >> Would JW> we be phased out of public image further with PT's expanded
> >> scope?  JW>  Is  it  truly an expansion of PT's scope now, or as they
> >> claim,  just JW> given the right words for what they have always been
> >> doing?  What  is JW> our true unique domain then, something that only
> >> we  can  and only we JW> are allowed to do ( restricted acts)? Or, is
> >> there  one?  What  is  PT's JW> compared to ours? These questions are
> >> hopefully  being  answered  by  JW> someone at APTA and AOTA as these
> >> professions  are heading towards a JW> very interesting decade or two
> >> ahead  of us. I expect some major JW> changes not only in how the way
> >> we  practice and our professions end JW> up by 2020, but also how the
> >> outside  world  perceives  us  as we JW> struggle in this interesting
> >> healthcare market. Joe
>
> >> JW>  -----  Original  Message  -----  From:  Amanda K. Dobyns To: JW>
> >> [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, August 28, 2003 8:00 PM Subject: JW>
> >> Re: [OTlist] PT does it all!!
>
> >> JW>  Unfortunately,  the  young  girl  who  was  quoted  in the story
> >> probably  JW> did not understand the difference between the two types
> >> of  therapy JW> she received during her rehabilitation. In my limited
> >> clinical  JW> experience, I have been called a PT more times than you
> >> would JW> believe. I think it goes to show that more client education
> >> is JW> necessary if our profession is to be better understood.
>
> >> JW> Amanda
>
> >> JW> on 8/28/03 7:20 PM, Ron Carson at [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
>
> >> JW> > Hello:
>
> >> JW> > Today, at a medical supply company, I picked up the Spring 2003
> >> JW>  edition  > of a magazine called "FAAST Access". The magazine has
> >> JW> something to do > with assistive technology. On page 19 there's a
> >> JW> story line about a young > girl with a spinal cord injury and how
> >> JW>  her life was made better by a > piece of technology. Now, here's
> >> JW> the really unfortunate part of the > story.
>
> >> JW> > I quote:
>
> >> JW>  >  "As soon as I was able, I started physical therapy to improve
> >> my JW> > independence with daily activities. The therapists were able
> >> to  JW>  teach  me  >  how  to  dress  and  perform  all  of my daily
> >> activities,  JW>  except  getting  in  > and out of my chair from the
> >> floor."
>
> >> JW>  >  So,  not only is the PT profession saying that they teach JW>
> >> self-care,  > magazine articles are doing it as well. By the way, JW>
> >> this  is  not  the  >  first  time I read about PT teaching daily JW>
> >> activity.
>
> >> JW> > Ron
>
> >> JW>                               >                               JW>
> >> *****************************??**********************************
>
> >> JW> > To remove yourself from the OTnow mail list, send a message to:
>
> >> JW> > [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> >> JW> > In the message's *body*, put the following text:
>
> >> JW> > unsubscribe OTlist
>
> >> JW> > -
>
> >> JW> > List messages are archived at:
>
> >> JW> > http://www.mail-archive.com/[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> >> JW>                               >                               JW>
> >> *****************************??***********************************
>
> >> *****************************��**********************************
>
> >> To remove yourself from the OTnow mail list, send a message to:
>
> >> [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> >> In the message's *body*, put the following text:
>
> >> unsubscribe OTlist
>
> >> -
>
> >> List messages are archived at:
>
> >> http://www.mail-archive.com/[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> >> *****************************��***********************************
>
> JW> *****************************��**********************************
>
> JW> To remove yourself from the OTnow mail list, send a message to:
>
> JW> [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> JW> In the message's *body*, put the following text:
>
> JW> unsubscribe OTlist
>
> JW> -
>
> JW> List messages are archived at:
>
> JW> http://www.mail-archive.com/[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> JW> *****************************��***********************************
>
>
> *****************************��**********************************
>
> To remove yourself from the OTnow mail list, send a message to:
>
> [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> In the message's *body*, put the following text:
>
> unsubscribe OTlist
>
> -
>
> List messages are archived at:
>
> http://www.mail-archive.com/[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>
> *****************************��***********************************
>


*****************************��**********************************

To remove yourself from the OTnow mail list, send a message to:

[EMAIL PROTECTED]

In the message's *body*, put the following text:

unsubscribe OTlist

-

List messages are archived at:

http://www.mail-archive.com/[EMAIL PROTECTED]

*****************************��***********************************

Reply via email to