Hi! On Thu, Sep 07, 2006 at 10:23:39AM +1000, Adam Kennedy wrote: > >- has_example > > I thought we were generally negative on this one, because it would > encourage people to spuriously add trivial example directories to their > distributions...
Yes, but I've recently introduced the concept of 'optional' metrics. Optional metrics are not used to calculate an authors rank in the CPANTS game. Current optional metrics are 'is_prereq' and 'has_examples'. This also makes it possible to get 110% kwalitee at the moment :-) > As a secondary point, if we keep it you might also want to include > /sample(s)/ and /demo(s)/. Thanks, added > > - declares_dependencies > > It might be an interesting idea to also add a "dependencies_exist" > metric, that makes sure that all the dependencies that are declared > actually exist in the CPAN. Dunno, could be of dubiously little value, > but I just managed to somehow upload something with bad deps that I had > installed on my local machine, but that weren't all on CPAN yet... It might also catch possible CPANTS bugs. > > - no_open_bugs > > If we are going to do this, we have to make sure that we DON'T include > wishlist bugs in this metric, or it blows the validity all to hell. I was thinking of something like 'no open bugs with severity > wishlist (or even unimportant) and more than two weeks old'. 'Taken' bug reports are obviously also not counted. > > - Signature checking ? > > I looked into this a bit more recently, with all the Module::Signature > changes. I think this is a bad idea. > .. I agree > > - has_rating ? > > Bad idea I think as well, because it will encourage spurious ratings. > This is the same reason that ratings aren't factored into the > search.cpan result order. CPAN Ratings currently has most of it's value > because it doesn't matter much, and so it encourages high quality reviews. I also do not really like this metirc, I just wrote it down because it was suggested some time ago. -- #!/usr/bin/perl http://domm.zsi.at for(ref bless{},just'another'perl'hacker){s-:+-$"-g&&print$_.$/}
