Surprisingly Manoj, I am for the most part in agreement with you. Thank you for being concise.
There is only one point I question... Britain knew there would probably be a partitian but I thought it was accomplished after Independence. Why is there such a huge difference between Bangladesh politics and those of Pakistan. Both were formed at the same time and both of "indian-moslems", no ?? any thoughts would be appreciated. On 1/11/09, MANOJ <[email protected]> wrote: > > Because of conquests, invasion, ethnic cleansing - there were > migrations. > > e.g. Buddhists were slaughtered (mens slaughtered/women raped) from > Afghanistan and now it is an Islamic country. > > On 1947, after India got independence from British colonial rule, > Muslims demanded a portion because they feared that a Hindu majority > Government may marginalize them. They threatened that if a separate > nation for them is not carved out, they will destroy India by Jihad. > After a land was given, the slaughtered all men from Pakistan and > raped all women. The formula of ethnic cleansing. > > Now, you may see, after 60 years, how India and Pakistan maintained > their territory. While secular India is in path of progress and > prosperity, Pakistan has become the epicenter of 'Terror'.. > > The 'Ottomans' and British people allowed them legally to immigrate, > just like USA allowed 2.5 million Jews to immigrate. Why in USA it is > legal and in Palestine that is illegal. > > Also, when some one immigrates, he buys land and try to settle there. > The British had a 'Jews regiment' in their Army, who fought with > Palestinians in war. So obviously, they were Jews sympathizers , while > they were at the helm of affairs of Palestine. The same British, > allowed carving of Muslim country 'Pakistan' out of India, for the > same very reason and the Islamic world is silent about that. WHy > silent ? Because they were beneficiary ? > > Case-1 > How did Muslims found in India ? By Invasion/ conversion., when Hindus > were not at the helm of affairs. > > case-2 > How did jews end up in Palestine ? By Lawful immigration, when > Palestinians were not at the helm of affairs . > > Why case-1 is right and why case-2 is wrong ? > > > Also, How did Palestinians lost their land in 1948 ? By attacking > Israel. Didn't they thought the consequence of losing a war ? Lost & > screwed up ? > > What if Palestinians/Arabs were won the war ? All Jews men would have > been slaughtered and all Jews women would have been raped and Now we > would be seeing another Afghanistan. > > > > While in case of Palestine, they are shouting because they couldn't do > an ethnic cleansing of Jews, just like they did for Hindus in Pakistan/ > Bangladesh. > > > > > > > > On Jan 9, 2:39 pm, "Emin Mahmutovic" <[email protected]> wrote: > > For Palestinian state... > > There were not actually Jews living in that "province" until Ottomans let > > them to immigrate in 4 sacred cities... And with exception of Ancient > > History there were no Jews in there before Ottomans came (except small > > number of them)... > > So, where is legitimacy to get gift from England to give Israel state to be > > established where Jews didn't live???? > > > > For Iraq... > > "Iraqis ended up with their sovereignty, democracy, and friendship with the > > United States." > > > > - i dont believe that even you believe in your story... heheheh ... So, lets > > forget war, atrocities and fight between Sunnis and Shias (really hard one) > > after you " brought them democracy"... Democracy is not possible in middle > > east... I have lived there .. they are not so mature, so don't believe in > > folktale of democracy until you experience it there ... > > > > Iraq... We will see what will happen after US stops with paying Sunis to > > defend themself... I thing that this program ends soon and then Iraq will be > > in the news again... > > > -- Mark M. Kahle Blessed are the bewildered for they don't know the difference.... Me --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ Thanks for being part of "PoliticalForum" at Google Groups. For options & help see http://groups.google.com/group/PoliticalForum * Visit our other community at http://www.PoliticalForum.com/ * It's active and moderated. Register and vote in our polls. * Read the latest breaking news, and more. -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
